Board Thread:Episode Discussions/@comment-25319479-20160818105554/@comment-734582-20160824101611

ChibiBuu wrote: I don't even get why is Obito in those alternate realities still without one of his sharingan, it's so farfetch'd and dumb. Since he would've died without Madara, he likely imagines himself as being redeemed after his whole incident. And his Sharingan was explicitly a gift, would be very awkward to say afterwards "yea remember my dying words?"

Ajr1218 wrote: As for Obito being unredeemable, well, he made it clear himself that nothing could be done, which is (partially) why he seeked death. Even then, neither Kishi nor Pierrot tried to explain these kinds of things, which leaves Obito's redemption just as half-baked as the decision to make Obito into a bad guy in the first place. He was a jinchuriki who had his beast extracted, which guarantees death. Then, he used Rinne Tensei, which guarantees death. Obito couldn't be saved. This is why he was willing to die. and given that he couldn't even use Susanoo with both eyes present, it seems his body was too weak to really use his full potential, which is why he came back to Kakashi.

Considering other things, like the Cursed Puppet seal and the half-zetsu body, one can ask how much Obito truly was himself. Also note that with his Mangekyou power, he must've felt reality was very much a joke. (not unlike Itachi who's genjutsu made him question reality).