Board Thread:Theories and Speculation/@comment-45444155-20200715142058/@comment-45444155-20200717082750

LegionZero wrote: ReweR 1331 wrote:

You don't get it. In fact, yes, the result is the same, but because of the way this chakra is achieved, their eyes are different. The Madara chakra evolved when the Sasuke chakra just had a ready-made CSP, ready Rinnegan. Exactly because he has a ready-made Rinnegan, he can add Sharingan to it. I dont know what you mean by "ready made" but it doesnt matter if it is obtained through mixing or from the source, it is the same chakra.

1+3= 4

0+4= 4

At the end of it all, 4 is still 4

ReweR 1331 wrote:

Madara can't do that because his chakra has evolved naturally, the eyes can only accept one of the properties of his eyes - either Rinnegan or Sharingan. I thought that was obvious to everyone. -_- it is obvious he cant use both at once. What isnt obvious is why.

But anyone who reads the databook knows Hagoromo gave Sasuke his Rinnegan. And anyone who watched/read the series knows it is not a standard Rinnegan

ReweR 1331 wrote:

Madara made it clear that Sasuke has one Rinnegan out of two. (片や輪廻眼を開眼したか) Are you just running that through online translation programs?

ReweR 1331 wrote:

That is, we were immediately informed in the original that Sasuke wasn't full power. + we can remember that the true power of the eyes is achieved only in pairs. You can't deny that Sasuke has the full power of Rinnegan, and that 1 of his Rinnegan = 2 of Madara's Rinnegans. Sasuke never had 2 Rinnegan so he was at full power.

Sasuke's Rinnegan is special. It clearly doesnt follow the rules of a basic Rinnegan. For all we know it is some halfway point between Rinnegan and Rinnesharingan, which only comes in one eye

ReweR 1331 wrote:

Minato divided Kurama into Yin and Yang. Half of them still had chakra, so Hagoromo could do the same with his. And it never made a difference in the Kurama's abilities. They were exactly the same and still could use Yin or Yang chakra.

If Hagoromo gave him Yin Chakra, it is still chakra, made of physical and spiritual energy. Sasuke would still get both

No, I'm not telling you it's a different chakra. I'm just talking about how it's obtained. Madara got it from his, and Sasuke got it from outside, from Hagoromo. It's like the fruit of the chakra, someone gets Rinnegan at once, and someone, because of genetic predisposition, develops it himself.

Sasuke already has a ready chakra that gives him Rinnegan, because he can activate Sharingan, Byakugan with him. Rinnegan Madara is the result of changing his chakra, not introducing a ready-made chakra into his system like Sasuke. It's obvious to everyone, it's elementary.

Yeah, what's wrong with that? I also use jardic.

Madara clearly says the Sasuke has one Rinnegan. Exactly noted that one of the two / of the pair. This indicates that 1 Rinnegan Sasuke = 1 Rinnegan Madara, but 1 Rinnegan Sasuke ≠ 2 Rinnegan Madara. Madara could just say that Sasuke awakened Rinnegan, but no, he noted that Sasuke awakened one Rinnegan of two.

Yes, I agree with you here, even if he gave the Yin chakra, that chakra still carries spiritual and physical energy.