Board Thread:Naruto Discussions/@comment-3568954-20140625232535/@comment-3568954-20140626115343

Elveonora wrote: I might have your sense of humor, but I'm not you. It's entirely possible to have power akin to X without having X.

in the context of the show it is not

the Sharingan is the eye that reflects the soul. with out the sharingan its not possible to use the power of the sharingan. the only way it is possible is if you had already had the sharingan like Madara.

hagoromo said beside the byakugan his mother had the power of the sharingan and with those eye powers(key word eye powers ie she had the sharingan) she created a gruesome jutsu(Infinite Tsukoyomi) that there disproves your X with out X theory