Board Thread:Consensus Track/@comment-4522253-20181001230600/@comment-4522253-20181016202159

WindStar7125 wrote: The proposed draft infobox for Tools removes the slideshow in the infobox. Ideally we'd like to keep those in the infoboxes that use slideshows along with maintaining tabbers in infoboxes that use them (such as character infoboxes). Not to mention in the draft, the "Name" sub-infobox listing the different names of the subject looks different from the current infoboxes, particularly the lack of appearance of the words "Kanji", "Rōmaji" and "Alternative names" in their respective parameters. I would think we'd like those to be formatted the same way you format the "Literal English" and "English anime" parameters in your draft for Tools. Those were intentional alterations.

The elimination of the Infobox/Slideshow helper template is by design, as that's handled by Lua now and creates a tabber where appropriate. An actual slideshow that changes images is actually a readability and usability issue, and is not possible on mobile, regardless. Being able to focus on one image at a time and select an alternative is the preferred data thinking, and timed transitions between images were intentionally omitted from PI capabilities.

The alternate showing of names also is clear data-delineation, as it is fairly apparent what the differences are in kanji and romaji and making labels for them is both redundant and considered oversimplified bad design. Marking them as Japanese is also unnecessary, as that's assumed. From a data-first and readability / usability perspective, placing them at the same level as the English title is both more appropriate and reads better. I understand that it's a change, but I hope that you will consider it is a change for good reason. I'd also like to consider consolidating both the English and Japanese titles above the image, for consistency.