Board Thread:Theories and Speculation/@comment-1512913-20161115123051/@comment-1512913-20161119172249

Seelentau wrote: Damn... so because the databook contains errors on previously established information (Madara's Izanagi, Danzo's Kuchiyose), a completely NEW information can be erroneous as well? Of course That's not how it works. If there was an earlier statement that suggested Magnet Release to be Fire + Wind (for example), THEN the databook would be wrong. But there is no such statement, the databook information can not contradict anything, because it's the single fact we have on that matter. Do you understand that? If there was a new statement that stated Magnet Release is Fire + Wind (again, for example), then it would contradict the fourth databook (and of course the Scorch Release thing, but that's not the topic). Until that happens, Magnet Release is Wind + Earth, based on a logical conclusion. '''Exactly, based on logical conclusion from a possibly wrong picture, not based on an undeniably factual statement. Right now it's only true, because nothing else says it's not, but there is a possibility that Rasa's natures might be wrong''' By the way, the manga itself contains errors as well. So you disregard the whole manga as a viable source of information as well? '''Not the entire manga, but everything related to an error. Take the Obito-Kakashi timeline for example, manga and databook don't fit and suggest different things, so both can be potentially wrong''' And no, I'm not going to explain again. My sermon above was directed at myself (think Bart in The Simpsons' intro-style). Can you at least link me to where you explained it the last time?