Board Thread:Versus Debates/@comment-26005711-20150515175138/@comment-26383345-20150515215424

Madara would win. He had the same kind of power as Hagoromo, but he had a lot more battle experience gained through a lifetime of struggle. Hagoromo was born with a lot of power and has been a Jinchuuriki of the Juubi for the vast majority of his life. Madara has spent a full lifetime as a man without any divine power, working his way up the ladder, developing his power and becoming powerful enough to become one of the two strongest shinobi in the entire world. When he became the Juubi Jinchuuriki, he took with it all of that experience, the Sharingan's battle prowess and an understanding of the power he was dealing with. Given a year or so, Madara would have known every single thing there would be to know about his new power. If he would fight Hagoromo at that point, he would destroy him completely.