Board Thread:Theories and Speculation/@comment-45273751-20200322060033/@comment-4961229-20200411043454

Babyfriend1 wrote: Okay I retract "all the chakra" being the ingredients for all-killing ash bones. BZ stating that a large amount of the chakra that had been scattered in the world was necessary doesn't mean there weren't specific pieces of chakra that had been scattered that were essential. For example if I said "a cake requires many ingredients" I only specify the quantity of ingredients needed and yet you don't assume that that means having a lot of random ingredients will help you meet that requirement. Why do you think it had to be specified that the required chakra had to be the chakra that had been scattered in the world ie the chakra that originated from kaguya as opposed to chakra from the otsutsuki living on the moon or from the tenseigan or god trees on other planets or a new god tree on earth or any other source? If anything, black zetsu's statement confirms that not just any chakra will work.

All-killing ash bones isn't the bone-manipulating ability kaguya has but a derivative of it? (separate question) Are you saying shikotsumyaku is a component of kaguya? Okay, I'll accept that it had to be Kaguya's scattered chakra. However, BZ's statement also confirms that she only needed PART of her scattered chakra to be reborn.

His exact words were, "So as planned, the Infinite Tsukuyomi was launched during this war and by amassing a large amount of the HUMAN chakra that'd been scattered mother was restored." We know for a fact that even Ninja cats were assimilated. They weren't human and yet their chakra now resides in Kaguya, so we know for a fact that not all of the chakra that resides in Kaguya was essential to her rebirth and definitely not essential to All-Killing Ash Bones.

How would you determine which of those scattered pieces were essential for her rebirth? Furthermore, how would you determine which of those essential rebirth pieces were crucial specifically for the All-Killing Ash Bones jutsu? How would you rule out that the essential piece of All-Killing Ash Bones came not from ANY of those scattered chakras, but from 1) the Divine Tree that Madra absorbed or 2) Black Zetsu himself, since he's also part of the equation?

That's all I was talking about with my "something missing" comment.

That's my understanding of it. It's a specific jutsu of her ability, the way Dance of the Seedling Fern is a specific jutsu of Shitotsumyaku.

Yes. Anything derived from Kaguya is a component of Kaguya. In other words, they were part of her scattered human chakras, a part that was never recovered. Only some components were essential to Kaguya's rebirth, like Senju and Uchiha. Other components of Kaguya were nonessential, like that Damiyo we saw get assimilated. All he provided was a drop of chakra.

I want to thank you for having a civil and well thought debate, regardless of the conclusion. You don't find that often anywhere on the Internet.