Board Thread:Theories and Speculation/@comment-34661853-20181111160651/@comment-26107879-20181115013845

@Elve

What page in the Databook. Cause that makes no sense. How is Madara and Hashirama able to be edo tensei if their souls are in Naruto and Sasuke already?

Reincarnation nakes note that only the Chakra and will is passed on, nothing about the soul.

@Legion

I don't see anything cryptic about it. Kabuto stated he was using Hashirama's cells and his healing to heal Sasuke. Can't get anymore obvious than that.

You also don't need Sharingan to get Rinnegan, that cannot be argued with. Momoshiki has nothing other than Rinnegan. Kaguya has none other than Rinne-Sharingan, Sharingan is a mutation of Rinnegan which is a mutation of Rinne-Sharingan. You guys are looking at the evolution like this,

Sharingan -> Mangekyo -> Eternal Mangekyo -> Rinnegan -> Rinne-Sharingan.

When you should be looking at it like this.

Rinne-Sharingan -> Rinnegan -> all Sharingans.

Kaguya and the Otsutsukis shown you don't need a Sharingan. Now whether if Hagaromo started with Sharingan or not, can be debated. He had it in A Canon but not K Canon. K Canon stated what he had was a Kekkei Mora. K Canon > A Canon. But Momoshiki has shown he has Rinnegan and not Sharingan.

What Sasuke's and Urashiki's eye is can only be theorized. It can be another new mutation. It can be a mutation in between Rinne-Sharingan and Rinnegan. It can be something else. It will probably be explained later on when Urashiki is further developed in the story.

@SenjuMadara

Momoshiki and Urashiki destroy that theory of needing Sharingan. The fact that they even have Rinnegan shows that you don't need Hagoromo's Chakra anymore and therefore is retconned. How would they get Chakra from someone they never met? I used to somewhat think that it was possible that you needed EMS, but then they were introduced and that theory was no longer possible too me.