Board Thread:Theories and Speculation/@comment-26894845-20151212061943/@comment-734582-20151213130052

UltimaDude wrote: @Thekillman I disagree. If a non-trasmigrant can awaken the Rinnegan then Black Zetsu would of thought it and tried to to make a non-trasmigrant to habor Asura's and Indra's Chakra or do it himself Black Zetsu tried it on a dozen and potentially more Transmigrants and failed. It took him a thousand years to reawaken Kaguya with the people that have the highest change of awakening the Rinnegan to begin with and even then the one Transmigrant that did needed decades for the changes to show. I believe it´s possible for a non-transmigrant to awaken rinnegan. It's a lot more difficult, as Obito himself pretty much proves. But difficult and unlikely are not the same as impossible. Elveonora wrote: It's more like having lots of the pieces MAKES/EQUALS one an incarnate. close, but not entirely. Hagoromo says that he could see why "Ashura chose you", which suggests it's a bit more than just having the pieces. Since there seems to be no clear lineage between transmigrants, i think the scattered chakra by itself wishes to rearrange into a full being. If sufficient pieces are together, essentially Ashura/Indra can re-emerge. However, it seems that the pieces can most definitely vary and it also seems that this re-emergence is not perfect (Naruto sensed something like Ashura but never truly had a Jinchuriki-esque relationship).

It seems that it's closer to Avatar's reincarnation cycle, in that each Transmigrant is linked via their chakras but still a unique being.

QuakingStar wrote: I honestly and fully believe if Obito was at full health/chakra and was not dying he would have awakened dual Rinnegan. I think the same. Before being a Jinchuriki he may eventually have awakened it, but the probability was low. Since being the Juubi Jinchuriki and having a Rinnegan implanted, awakening the Rinnegan himself was pretty much guaranteed. However, death by Rinne Tensei is an absolute rule and even after being kept alive by Zetsu and Naruto's healing, he still knew he would die.