Board Thread:Wiki Discussions/@comment-1512913-20140521221412/@comment-3568954-20140523092624

Elveonora wrote: @Hagoromo, wat... @Foxie, fair enough. Tho my whole point is, that her third eye actually wasn't called a Sharingan. We've been only told that she had power of Sharingan. There was no arrow pointing at her forehead. If Kishi had written "power of Rinnegan" instead, it wouldn't have made sense, since the Infinite Tsukuyomi isn't cast with a Rinnegan.

Basically, if you were to put two identical dogs in front of me and call one of them a duck, you wouldn't fool me. Rinnegan-looking Sharingan looking exactly like Sharingan-looking Rinnegan doesn't make any sense whatsoever, even less so considering that Kaguya was stronger than Hagoromo. Why would the original Sharingan turn into a Rinnegan and then into a weaker Sharingan, then magically turning into a stronger Rinnegan, which just happens to resemble the original Sharingan? Even an idiot has to see that it can't be true. Not everything is going to be spoon fed to us.

sasuke and kaguya's eyes are not identical just count the tamoe and the placement is upside down from each other. also if you look at pictures of her she only has a red slit on her forhead sometimes it is opened with a third eye. but based on what madara said(that if you get close to the moon the third eye opens which allows you to cast IT) that implies that her third eye is the sharingan also everyone assumed it was a sharingan when he mentioned it because it looks like a sharingan