Board Thread:Theories and Speculation/@comment-890307-20161205161301/@comment-30426414-20161219155817

Namikazenaruto9 wrote: @Lorenzo Von MT And how do you suggest that "merging" of the two eyes take place?

In a world where people can implant cells from person to person with perfect compatibility and magically heal most wounds with chakra, its not farfetched at all how two sharingan can be merged. I'm not going to assume how its done because of course thats just an assumption.

Ravenlot 27 wrote: The whole "merging" theory is technically one big assumption, while '''it's kinda clear that user's eyes are just replaced by the eyes of a transplantee. The words of Itachi alone should be enough proof to this, he stated that Izuna's (MS) eyes were literally passed down''' to Madara as their new wielder, which made them stronger and caused the light to never fade. Yeah, Itachi didn't know that Izuna's eyes weren't stealed, but given willingly as a gift, yet Madara's story he told Sasuke was correct more or less.

The swapping theory is a big assumption as well, its an even bigger assumption because you have to speculate the reason why the eye patterns are merged, you then have to speculate how the EMS abilities are stronger than the MS abilities, then you have to speculate how swapping two sets of blind eyes will automatically cure the blindness. There are too many assumptions with this theory, with the merging theory, you only have to make one assumption: fusion, and it answers all those questions above.

Moreover, itachi's words don't prove anything, all he said was they are passed down but he wasn't clear about how they were passed down.

Thekillman wrote: I'd be far more accepting of that theory, if it weren't for the fact that nothing like this was shown. Eyes are physically transplanted to gain power all the time. Kakashi didn't just fuse his eyes with Obito's. Nagato didn't fuse his eyes with the Rinnegan. Nothing like this eye fusion is ever shown.

Why would the EMS then be the exception? Why would it go against the trend?

This is because you are comparing completely different situations. The requirement for the EMS is to transplant another MS from a person with strong blood ties to the transplantee. The rinnegan, sharingan, byakugan etc don't have that requirement, thats why this situation is different.