User talk:Omnibender/Elemental recomposition table

Ideas from Periodic Table?
While I was looking around, I found a Japanese periodic table on the internet and suddenly thought the elements with kanji may help fill the table. I'm not sure if it'll exactly help, but you could take a look at it if you wanted to. A possible combination to Earth and Lightning related ones may be in here somewhere. --GoDai (talk) 05:55, October 14, 2011 (UTC)

There are lots of usable elements but I guess they are only usable when there are triple combinations that work by creating an imbalance by using more of one compound than the other (example: Earth + Earth + Lightning). Chemical releases are a complicated thing and would take time to know how to place the compounds and are unlikely to ever be added be it canon recomposition or Omnibender's table. Metallic recompositions are also unlikely to be ever added since we saw the Iron and Gold Sand techniques (by that I want to remind of possible Copper, Silver, Tin or Lead Sand techniques). But the following list of ideas features just examples of how you could use chemical elements and metals as triple element recompositions.

"Chemical releases" as I call them could be:
 * Boron (硼素, Hōso) and Boron Release (硼遁, Hōton)
 * Nitrogen (窒素, Chisso) and Nitrogen Release (窒遁, Chitton)
 * Fluorine (弗素, Fusso) and Fluorine Release (弗遁, Futton)
 * Silicon (珪素, Keiso) and Silicon Release (珪遁, Keiton)
 * Sulphur (硫黄, Iō) and Sulphur Release (硫遁, Ryūton)
 * Arsenic (砒素, Hiso) and Arsenic Release (砒遁, Hiton)
 * Bromine (臭素, Shūso) and Bromine Release (臭遁, Shūton)
 * Iodine (沃素, Yōso) and Iodine Release (沃遁, Yōton)

"Metallic releases" as I call them could be: ...too bored to list more metals.
 * Iron (鉄, Tetsu/Kurogane) and Iron Release (鉄遁, Tetton)
 * Gold (金/鋆, Kane) and Gold Release (金遁/鋆遁, Kinton/Inton); (鋆: common Chinese character I prefer)
 * Copper (銅, Dō/Akagane) and Copper Release (銅遁, Dōton)
 * Silver (銀, Gin/Shirogane) and Silver Release (銀遁, Ginton)
 * Tin (錫, Suzu) and Tin Release (錫遁, Shakuton)
 * Lead (鉛, Namari) and Lead Release (鉛遁, Enton)
 * Zinc (亜鉛, Aen) and Zinc Release (鋅遁, Shinton); (鋅: common Chinese character I prefer)
 * Platinum (白金, Hakkin) and Platinum Release (鉑遁, Hakuton) (鉑: common Chinese character I prefer)

Since it would take too much time to figure out fitting compounds for each idea I didn't do that. DarkblueFlow (talk) 01:23, October 15, 2011 (UTC)

Right, but an "imbalance" isn't exactly necessary, since it's not like we're using all of the chemical elements, I beleive we are prioritizing getting at least one idea for each combination. If we can make a good connection to any of these elements with Lightning, we have good options. For example, we could usemetals that are commonly used as common anodes and/or cathodes and consider them as choices. And while we probably won't see a lot of metallic natures since Magnet Release manipulates metal as a weapon anyway, it's still possible, since Kishi can always come up with a similar thing that has a different purpose. --GoDai (talk) 04:22, October 15, 2011 (UTC)

Wind and Lightning
With that combination, what do you think of a disintegrate nature? Both wind and lightning cuts well, and lightning could focus the wind towards one specific point. Jacce | Talk | Contributions 15:36, October 15, 2011 (UTC)
 * I'm curious on what wind and lightning will turn out to be. I can see Magnet being lightning with either earth or wind. If it turns out to be lightning and earth, which I find more likely, I have no idea what will be used for lightning and wind. The only reason I have Swift Release in there is because it's an idea with a higher canon standing than my own, I try to find a place for those before coming up with my own ideas. Omnibender - Talk - Contributions 23:36, October 15, 2011 (UTC)
 * One idea I tend to cling to for Wind+Lightning is like, a resonating nature. Since both enhance how well weapons cut when used in chakra flow, it would be like the ultimate cutting chakra flow nature. --GoDai (talk) 23:37, October 16, 2011 (UTC)

Bonding Release?
I liked what Umishuru said about a "build/structure" nature. How about something like a "Bond Release"? The chakra would act as the intermolecular and intramolecular (and maybe even nuclear) bonds that "glue" particles to particles. Earth for the targeted matter, Lightning for the energy, and Yin for the form and the inwards pull. --GoDai (talk) 23:41, October 16, 2011 (UTC)
 * Kinda like an opposite of Dust Release, which instead of breaking stuff down at molecular level would put them together at molecular level, kinda welding or smelting perhaps? Omnibender - Talk - Contributions 00:10, October 17, 2011 (UTC)

Yeah, I was thinking about that too. An opposite of Dust Release, which would turn the "dust" into solid structures. When used on two difference substances, maybe some fusion of properties could happen. --GoDai (talk) 01:15, October 17, 2011 (UTC)
 * I don't necessarily see this as something turning "dust" into solids. I can see this working kinda by phasing stuff inside other stuff, maybe some active shaping of the stuff being manipulated as well. Omnibender - Talk - Contributions 01:20, October 17, 2011 (UTC)

Hmm yeah. Maybe something like "merging" or melding. --GoDai (talk) 17:20, October 21, 2011 (UTC)

It is a very good idea. In my opinion, a Structure (構造, Kōzō) nature and Structure Release (造遁, Zōton). It does not create matter out of nothingness, it gathers atoms and molecules from the surrounding area and uses them to create objects by integrating the molecules into the structure to create various different structures. This nature does not change the atoms into another (chemical) element, opening a weakness: If there's no "proper" matter around (stone or metal for example) you can only create structures out of the more unsuitable molecules around you. Also, gathering matter from a bigger distance requires more chakra. DarkblueFlow (talk) 19:04, November 12, 2011 (UTC)
 * Haha it kinda reminds me of a Fullmetal Alchemist nature. Are you experienced with Japanese? --GoDai (talk) 11:51, November 13, 2011 (UTC)
 * A Fullmetal Alchemist nature sounds good, but what I wrote is just an idea of this bonding release thing. There's no proper kanji for bonding so I decided to use structure instead, but 造 can mean creation too. Besides, the Rōmaji for Flesh Release need to be Nikuton, otherwise it would be wrong. So yeah, I am experienced in Japanese. XD (Be sure to use Earth/Lightning/Yin for Structure Release because I'm still hoping that Omnibender uses Earth/Lightning/Yang for Gravity Release.) DarkblueFlow (talk) 13:48, November 13, 2011 (UTC)

Ideas Pt. 12
For the Judgment release I was thinking of a energy that can cause great pleasure and healing and also when needed great pain. Sort of like the Heaven and Hell reward of Christianity.

Lightning + Water + Yang = Luck release. Symbolically you have to be unlucky in life to get hit by lightning since the chances are really low, Yang is seen as positive according to the table which can translate as lucky i guess and water is neutral but would act as the catalyst. Since water is seen as a purifying substance it would allow the energy or substance go from bad to good luck and so on a reflection on water's many states and ability to exist in varying temperature on opposite ends basically water adaptability.

Lightning + Water + Yin = Void release. Yin represents space and therefore void. A void a is a place with no matter, to achieve this Lighting provides the energy to break up bonds. Water pulls the separated mass towards it self in which Yin absorbs since it is seen as taking in on the table and wet. Yin also causes the yin/yang balance of an object to collapse removing its form and leaving nothing left. What is left is a void.

Earth + Lightning + Yin = Transition/Form/Matter/Energy/Material/Convert Release. Following the Wet release idea that deals with turning things into liquids, this element would deal with turning objects into energy(lightning) or into solid matter(Earth). Yin deals with form and would pass on its form manipulating qualities to the element as well as aid. If you want examples, as gas is hit and it can turn into energy or a solid state in which it color depends on what color the gas was originally.

Water + Lightning + Yang/Yin = Refraction/Bend release. Water has light refracting qualities. Lighting gives out light and could turn an object into thus. Yang enhances these qualities or Yin aids in manipulation of form. The idea is a energy or substance that causes objects to bend and contort.

As for the bonding release, a better name for it might be clump.

Lightning + Water + Yang/Yin = Flux/Ferro release. The idea is this:    Basically Lightning passes on its magnetic qualities on to water in which its strange shape qualities and color(when introduced to a magnet) are attributed to Yin or have Yang act as the magnet. You basically have a black magnetic water.Umishiru (talk) 04:46, November 11, 2011 (UTC)

The closest thing I ever got to something like luck was when I tried to make an Entropy Release for fire/water/lightning before the purification idea came along. It had to do with charges of water molecules changing when they change states. Void is kinda like Wind Release's vacuum for me. I'm still sold on the smelting/welding idea for lightning/earth/yin. The flexibility is something I had though for a possible Rubber Release, but Lava took rubber for itself. The ferrofluid idea looks like an interesting variety for Magnet Release. Omnibender - Talk - Contributions 01:24, November 12, 2011 (UTC)

Yeah I was going for a liquid version of Magnet Release.Umishiru (talk) 01:28, November 12, 2011 (UTC)

Alkali metals
I was considering other possible properties one could give to chakra in Naruto. Along with an idea of a viral chakra (Although I didn't think it would be a nature, your similar Miasma theory seemed to fit fairly well), I also previously thought of something like an ability related to manipulating the alkali metals, or some sort of similar substance. Visible traits such as their high reactivity with water and air would be a big factor. Although there could be a better place for such nature, the place it would fit most well in this case would be Earth/Lightning/Yang, I think. The lightning's characteristic of unstable energy (and how lightning is amplified by water) would be applied to Earth to produce an earth that would react violently in water, and if very reactive, spontaneously combust in air. An Alkali (アルカリ Arukari) nature, allowing for the use of Alkali Release (碱遁, Kenton) ninjutsu. I asked Shounensuki about this and he said although the term is uncommon, it should be fine for the nature name. I personally imagine the user producing metals, increasing in reactivity (From sodium all the way to cesium). And the term covers both alkaline substances and alkali metals so it also fits my general idea of something that could maybe be the opposite of Boil's acidic nature. I also thought we should try to stick with things that do sound like physical elements, because I felt Purification and Erase were borderline abstract. Oh if you do complete the table I hope we'll have time to revise it. ^^ --GoDai (talk) 05:53, November 8, 2011 (UTC)
 * Alkali is an interesting idea. My only concern is that Mei implied that she could manipulate the pH levels of the mist, meaning she can potentially make it into a strong base as well. Omnibender - Talk - Contributions 01:24, November 12, 2011 (UTC)
 * Hmm yeah you're probably right. For this nature, I'm mostly just thinking of pure alkali metals like Rubidium and Cesium, not bases like their hydroxide forms. So rather than focusing on bases, I'm focusing more on the metals themselves and their reactive characteristics like exploding in water. --GoDai (talk) 03:15, November 13, 2011 (UTC)

Sounds like something that goes under metal release.Umishiru (talk) 03:19, November 13, 2011 (UTC)

Yeah I thought that too but we also have Mercury, so I was thinking Metal as more of the general sense of metal we refer to in everyday life. --GoDai (talk) 11:49, November 13, 2011 (UTC)

Reaction

 * As cool sounding as that is, ferrofluid is actually made from tiny particles of iron that is put in a liquid, so this actually has to add some kind of earth chakra as well.

EDIT: Never mind, forget what i said. This could actually be used since magnet release uses a metal (shuriken, gold, etc.) to perform jutsus. My bad. I just read that it uses iron as well and automatically assumed. My bad. Joshbl56 04:37, November 11, 2011 (UTC)

your guess
Which of your advanced elements will come as true ? --Elveonora (talk) 01:32, November 12, 2011 (UTC)

To get techincal, we don't know really. One of his elements shave been made canon but were made canon through different names. It has his heat release idea which in the canon is Scorch release. Though I doubt Kishi uses this site for ideas.Umishiru (talk) 01:36, November 12, 2011 (UTC)

Haha, you never know. But seriously, I mean ... there are dozens of combinations possible and also I have a question for Omni: Do you think it makes a difference which element enhances whom ? I mean, is it the same if you combine water and wind as wind and water ? And what advanced nature you think is about to appear next? --Elveonora (talk) 01:41, November 12, 2011 (UTC)

Yes, I think it's the same if you combine wind and water or water and wind. I have no idea which nature will appear next. Assuming Scorch is Fire/Wind, Explosion is Fire/Lightning, and Magnet Earth/Lightning, next is Lightning/Wind. I really hoped that with the revelation of previous techniques as natures, such as Magnet and Explosion, that Gaara's sand sould be revealed as Earth/Wind. Omnibender - Talk - Contributions 02:00, November 12, 2011 (UTC)

Maybe the Sand is KKG of some sorts, its still not explained in detail about Gaara's powers. For example Roshi, he and his beast were able to use Lava. But was Lava the power of the beast and Roshi was able to use that thanks to it or its Roshi's KKG and the beast is able to use it while Roshi transformed ?

Also I think its a difference which applies first. Isn't it different if you apply Wind to Earth thus earth thats sharp and thin, and Earth to Wind thus wind able to change it's solidity/density ? Or Fire to Wind = Scorch and Wind to Fire thus sharp and thin fire ? (Laser) Because each chakra nature has 2 properties/behaviors:

But: However, there are exceptions to this in the "form of some mediums" (meaning its possible to control existing/real fire as well) example example 2
 * Fire Release: It is performed by moulding "superheated chakra" inside the stomach before releasing it via the lungs and mouth (so it's actually not fire just hot chakra) example

But: Wind techniques are usually performed by "generating air circulation and can be enhanced through this method as well" (control of real wind source/medium) example example 2
 * Wind Release: It is performed by "manipulating chakra to be as sharp and thin as possible" (sharp and thin chakra) example

But: Lightning is much more powerful when it "utilises natural lightning" example
 * Lighting Release: Allows the user to "generate lightning by increasing the high frequency vibrations of their chakra", allowing for piercing damage and fast movement, the electricity paralyses the target (fast vibrating chakra) example

But: Or to create it; be it dirt, mud, or rock and have the "ability to change the strength and composition" of the earth from being as hard as metal to as soft as clay example example 2 example 3
 * Earth Release: Allows the user to "manipulate the surrounding earth" example

But: Or create their own, by "turning their chakra into water" example Water Release techniques can not only "change shape but state as well" example 2
 * Water Release: Allows the user to "manipulate pre-existing water" example

What I'm trying to say that nature transormations are able to use pre-existing mediums, change chakra into an element or combine elemental chakra with pre-existing medium. Thus it's a difference if you add Earth Release properties into already existing earth or other source, create earth from chakra or just add Earth Release properties into something for example Sand/Raikage as Onoki did.

So it's possible to add Wind Release properties into real water, to add Wind Release properties into Water Release water. So it's a difference which elemental property is applied first and into what.

So it's not the same if you combine lighting/earth or earth/lighting. As I said, there are dozens of combinations possible. --Elveonora (talk) 03:13, November 12, 2011 (UTC)

So ? Also I think Sand is Wind+Earth, I have my own theories of course only if you are interested. --Elveonora (talk) 02:14, November 13, 2011 (UTC)

While its an interesting theory, elemental fusion is simultaneous. That means Wind + Earth is the same as Earth + Wind. One after the other is collaboration.Umishiru (talk) 02:24, November 13, 2011 (UTC)

Well this entire "properties" thing is basically what I preach all the time :P. However, from what we've seen, there isn't going to be 20 combinations because there's a fixed pattern. Copy-pasting from what I proposed to Omnibender before: ''My current pattern theory for natures is that the "enhancing nature" affects the "main nature" in a counterclockwise direction on the nature transformation diagram. As I said before, Wind enhanced Water to create Ice, Fire enhanced Earth for Lava, Water to Lightning for Storm, Earth to Wind for some "solid wind" nature which Dust was previously a candidate for, and now, Lightning to Fire for Explosion. In my theory Ice can only be created from water, Lava from earth, Storm from lightning, and Explosion from fire, and Ice cannot be created from pre-existing wind, Lava cannot be created from fire, Storm cannot be created from water, and Explosion cannot be created from lightning (although unsure for now). My new idea is that this also applies to the adjacent element combinations. In a counterclockwise direction, Fire enhances Water to produce Boil, Water to Earth to produce Wood, Earth to Lightning to produce Magnetism (As the nature didn't create magnetic rocks or anything), Lightning to Wind for a theoretical "vibrating/fast/shattering wind", and Wind to Fire for Scorch, a phasing fire. Overall, Fire can be enhanced by Wind or Lightning, Wind can be enhanced by Lightning or Earth, Lightning can be enhanced by Earth or Water, Earth can be enhanced by Water or Fire, and Water can be enhanced by Fire or Wind. Kishimoto's more unorthodox natures like Storm seems to imply this pattern, which I plan to build on top of my old, partially failed theory. A counterclockwise direction may also be an interesting approach as opposed to the clockwise direct relationships the natures have.'' Oh and by the way the "opposite" and "adjacent" combinations are terms I used for my previous theory. In conclusion, I don't think there's going to be 20 kekkei genkai combinations because it looks like Kishi is showing us a pattern. When Lightning+Water turned out to be something no one really expected, I sensed this "direction of enhancement". If Water must enhance Lightning, Lightning will probably enhance Fire, Fire to Earth, Earth to Wind, and Wind to Water. It all makes sense so far, really. --GoDai (talk) 03:46, November 13, 2011 (UTC)
 * "Opposite" Recompositions:
 * Ice: Wind enhances Water; Floating ice; Can be produced from Water.
 * Lava: Fire enhances Earth; Molten earth; Can be produced from Earth. 
 * Storm: Water enhances Lightning; Fluid electricity; Can be produced from Lightning.
 * "Pressure"?: Earth enhances Wind; Solid air; Can be produced from Wind. (Previously thought of for Dust until it became a KT. I'm thinking since Gaara does not turn chakra into sand, he must be using a form of chakra that manipulates sand the way magnetism manipultes metal, which is why it's Magnetism Release, not Metal Release.)
 * Explosion: Lightning enhances Fire; Sudden combustion; Can be produced from Fire. (I previously had Blaze but I realized Explosion made so much more sense and it seems to work)
 * "Adjacent" Recompositions:
 * Scorch: Wind enhances Fire; Phasing heat; Can be produced from Fire. 
 * Boil: Fire enhances Water; Burning water; Can be produced from Water. 
 * Wood: Water enhances Earth; Trees growing from the earth in fluid forms; Can be produced from the Earth. 
 * Magnetism: Earth enhances Lightning; Magnetic energy; Can be produced from Lightning. 
 * "Resonate"?: Lighting enhances Wind; Vibrating air?; Can be produced from Wind. I see shockwaves in my mind, like the ones that you pointed out that were similar to Pulse.
 * Oh and I take a tiny bit of pride in Scorch Release, because I predicted Fire+Wind would be something along the lines of a superheated air. At the time Omnibender's table had Smoke fore Fire+Wind and Heat Release was an enhanced Fire, I think. I still do think Smoke would've worked out well too. --GoDai (talk) 03:57, November 13, 2011 (UTC)

I don't think so. It's not the same if you pour water into acid and acid into water. I will try to explain again. Wind+Earth, adding wind properties into earth as a medium. Earth+Wind, adding earth properties into wind as a medium.


 * Fire+Wind = Scorch (making wind release hot, evaporating water at a molecular level)
 * Wind+Fire = Laser (Sharp and Thin beams of fire)
 * Fire+Lighting = Flash (Lighting moving at speed of light)
 * Lighting+Fire = Heat (Highly vibrating waves of fire causing heat in weather)
 * Fire+Earth = Magma (Heated earth)
 * Earth+Fire = Lava (Fire with changed composition)
 * Fire+Water = Steam (Evaporating water)
 * Water+Fire = Boil/Acid (creating an acidic hot mist)
 * Wind+Lighting = Energy
 * Lighting+Wind = Explosion (Highly vibrating electrons [sparks] getting in contact with oxigen in a high air pressure causing an explosion)
 * Wind+Earth = Sand (wind cutting and shaping earth minerals into sand)
 * Earth+Wind = Crystal (Creating Crystals in the air from various compositions by increasing their density)
 * Wind+Water = Bubble (cutting and shaping water to create bubbles)
 * Water+Wind = Ice (making wind solid)
 * Lighting+Earth = Quake (vibrating thus shaking ground)
 * Earth+Lighting= Magnetism (increasing the potency of electrones)
 * Lighting+Water = Shock (rotating water under voltage)
 * Water+Lighting = Plasma/Storm Release (changing state and shape of electricity into beams of lighting)
 * Water+Earth = Mud (changing state of earth into liquid)
 * Earth+Water = Corrosion (increasing density and potency of water thus making the corrosion instant)

I have yin,yang,yin-yang and also 3 element combinations in mind but will post them later because its too long. If you are dunno where Wood is, just ask :P --Elveonora (talk) 09:38, November 13, 2011 (UTC)

Well I was previously one of those people that strongly beleived that there were going to be 20 combinations, a bit similar to your ideas. This was also supported by the fact that Mei's Lava Release was using a different kanji that could potentially mean "corrosion", although it turned out to be just lava in the anime. Anyway, the Japanese wording is crucial for me. You see, while pouring water into acid and pouring acid into water are different, that's not exactly how simultaneous nature transformation works, it's more like suddenly having water and acid mixed together without a certain order. They aren't mixing two different chakras, they're giving one body of chakra two properties at the same time to create a completely new chakra. The whole reason Kishi emphasized this is because: I hope that gives you an idea of what I think, and hopefully it gives you more ideas for discussion. I think you have a lot of similar ideas as me, like the Left Eye Fire and Right Eye Yin for Blaze (It makes sense because Uchiha have been attributed to those two :P). --GoDai (talk) 09:56, November 13, 2011 (UTC)
 * Nature Transformation, often misunderstood, is giving one's own chakra some properties to turn it into different forms of matter and energy. It basically "disguises" your chakra and makes the environment react the same way it would with the real thing, since "nature" refers to "properties" or "behavior". When one manipulates pre-existing elements, I believe they are using a small amount of this natured chakra to "pull" on rest of the already-existing element, making it follow the chakra's movements. I think you already said something similar, althought nature transformation is really both of the things you said. It gives things properties, but it does that because the chakra itself carries these properties, and one converts chakra into the element by giving the chakra near-identical properties.
 * Therefore, when one simultaneously gives their chakra the properties of two elements, they're basically creating something that's perfectly two things at the same time, in a way. In this case, Lava would be like Fire and Earth, both at the same time, since it carries both sets of properties. Now the big question is why doesn't it turn into a solid, dense fire then. I think of it as dominant and recessive characteristics, when they co-exist, some characteristics suppress others, resulting in a molten earth, with fire being the enhancing element and earth the enhanced element. Since Kishimoto clearly told us it was simultaneous transformation of two natures, it's actually logically impossible for there to be two different things, with the information we've been given. Don't get me wrong; 20 natures is extremely possible in this case, although it would be slightly awkward with what Kishi has told us.
 * Fire enhances Earth. Earth enhances Wind (unknown). Wind enhances Water. Water enhances Lightning. Ligthning enhances Fire. Next, Fire enhances Water, Water enahnces Earth, Earth enhances Lightning, Lightning enhances Wind (unknown), and Wind enhances Fire. All these make sense so far, and I find it quite strange that Kishi hasn't shown us any of the reverse of these(We haven't seen Lightning enhancing Water, Water enhancing Wind, and so on).
 * And I'm guessing you're going for the Wood is Earth/Water/Yang? XD --GoDai (talk) 09:56, November 13, 2011 (UTC)

Exactly with the Wood and Blaze stuff. Also I think 1st element is always used as an enhancer/amplifier and the 2nd one as a medium. It's still 2 natures used simultaneously just one applied to other. If it were combining both mediums and applying both to each other, the result from water and wind would be Blizzard with sharp and thin hail-stones that are able to change solidity or something. --Elveonora (talk) 11:30, November 13, 2011 (UTC)

Well, that's what I mean when I say they have dominant and recessive roles when their properties overlap. It's really about what's more natural and which one automatically and naturally takes which role for me. Since it is practically impossible to be solid and fluid at the same time, hot and cold at the same time, matter and energy at the same time, etc., the "simultaneously combined" result will appear to only bear some properties of one thing and some properties of another. Ice is made of water, but the ice mirrors float, which is similar to what we've seen for other Wind-related elements like Scorch and Dust, and possibly the nature responsible for sand manipulation. This is probably because they naturally fall into the roles, as a fluid wind is a bit redundant compared to, let's say, a fluid lightning. There's also quite a deal of Japanese traditional culture and the Godai involved. --GoDai (talk) 11:46, November 13, 2011 (UTC)

I like the way of your thinking, but im still after my theory :P Did you read all my combinations ? Also, how do you know about my Wood and Blaze stuff ? Did you read that or you think that as well ? : D --Elveonora (talk) 11:50, November 13, 2011 (UTC)

Well let's just say I think about every single possibility over and over again to reach the best conclusions. I read things everywhere, and the Blaze thing, I even have the Fire Yin thing on my page. The Wood thing was a guess, I've thought of the idea myself and I was wondering for only about 5 seconds when I saw that you didn't have Wood in your list. I was actually quite surprised when I saw you say a lot of your ideas, because they sounded extremely similar to what I mentioned quite a long time ago. --GoDai (talk) 12:23, November 13, 2011 (UTC)

About Sand Manipulation
For now, I think sand manipulation is granted by a nature that's not called Sand, although it may be vague. I did have "pressure" in the pattern theory I always preach, since I predict the combination of Earth and Wind will be Earth enhancing the Wind to create a "solid wind", which allows Gaara to manipulate sand. Sand is very often related to pressure, with a lot of Gaara's techniques being based on utilising it. I feel that the chakra being used is something like a mass of dense, pressurized air that is being used to shape the sand, because sand is the ideal material for such form of air to interact with, being easily carried by it. When Gaara crushes targets with sand he's using his chakra, infused inside, to press it in, and I imagine this chakra is in the form of something like dense, invisible air bubbles that push and carry the sand. It's really up for debate, and since it's so vague other ideas would be very welcome ^^. --GoDai (talk) 12:23, November 13, 2011 (UTC)
 * Magnetism Release manipulates metal. It does not turn chakra into metal, but rather into a metal-manipulating force.
 * "Pressure(? Or some other name.)" Release manipulates sand. It does not turn chakra into sand, but rather into a sand-manipulating force.

Im happy we have/had similar ideas. I think it's (again my part : D) Wind+Earth not Earth+Wind, because again theres wind cutting and shaping minerals in earth into sand. Earth+Wind I have for Crystal since its Earth Creating Crystals in the air from various particles by increasing their density. But who knows, maybe you are right and maybe I am ... or even both of us are wrong. Also do you know some other popular theories/speculations I should know about ? I have not read other's talkpages ... I'm new to this. So if ya have for me more interesting theories not limited to advanced natures, then bring them to me and we can discuss :P Also what do you think is with Kekkei Tota stuff ? I used to think something, but I changed it. --Elveonora (talk) 12:33, November 13, 2011 (UTC)

Well I do have my own theory page, and I'm sure several other people also have really good theory pages. Mine hasn't been updated for quite a while so there's a lot of my old theories in it. And kekkei tota is also another reason I don't think order matters; Kishi will go crazy if there's 6 different combinations for each set of 3 elements. --GoDai (talk) 20:34, November 13, 2011 (UTC)

Yeah, but what you think a Kekkei Tota is ? I don't think Kishi will go crazy, Im not saying he will reveal all the combinations before the manga's end just that its a possibility. --Elveonora (talk) 06:48, November 14, 2011 (UTC)

Disorder/Malfunction Release?
Yo I realized we didn't complete the discussion for your idea. I'm still not sure how I would phrase malfunction in one kanji yet. I was thinking something like disorder, but I'm not sure if it would convey the right message right at the first moment you hear it. From what you said, I'm thinking you're saying it's something like completely disabling systems, and hence screwing up and nullifying nearly anything? Or is this idea scrapped? --GoDai (talk) 11:58, November 13, 2011 (UTC)

Well other names for it could be break or fail release. The idea is like energy that causes objects to malfunction, misfire, or not work at all. For example, a fire ball jutsu is launch and collides with a fail release tech, depending on what the user wants the jutsu to do the fireball could miss the target, explode in the casters face if the element was launched early and fast enough or dissipate when it collides, sort of like a negating nature.Umishiru (talk) 18:54, November 13, 2011 (UTC)

If you're looking for a kanji, try 乱. It means riot, disorder or disturbance. Thus, a Disorder (混乱, Konran) nature and Disorder Release (乱遁, Ranton). A nature screwing any system up it comes in contact with, be it machines, living organisms or even attacks although the latter could lead to the presumption that it could even screw up molecules. In this case a more fitting name would be Chaos Release (The kanji would still fit.). But I'd say it consists of Water, Lightning and either Yin or Yang. I'm kind of tending to Yin, I don't know why. Well, water and lightning (electricity) are often the cause of malfunctioning in (electronical) systems. And Yin or Yang could empower these characteristics. DarkblueFlow (talk) 21:51, November 13, 2011 (UTC)

Well I believe my original or later suggestion was Lighting + Water + Yin.Umishiru (talk) 21:54, November 13, 2011 (UTC)

乱遁 for me means something more close to chaos, which many of us have already considered. I'm not too sure if the Error/Malfunction/Break/Fail concept of Water and Lightning are closely related enough. Maybe "Disruption" would be a better name. You might wanna ask Shounenuki to confirm the context of the kanji, to make sure it really fits. I feel the way the nature works is very similar to Scrambler's powers in X-men, which messed with systems, messing with and nullifying other jutsu by disrupting systems within them. --GoDai (talk) 01:22, November 14, 2011 (UTC)

Well a Scramble release is further from water. Other words coul dbe Jumble, Muddle, Confuse, Turmoil, Baffle, Mistake, Mess, Disarrange. After thinking about it, perhaps Disturb?Umishiru (talk) 21:11, November 14, 2011 (UTC)
 * Disturb would still use 乱 in the Release term. The nature term would change to 騒乱 (Sōran, lit.: Disturbance). Well, of course I'd still like to hear ShounenSuki's opinion to my translation. DarkblueFlow (talk) 21:52, November 14, 2011 (UTC)

swift release
Could Earth+Wind also be a combination for swift release since we now know that earth release can make objects weigh less and wind is already an element you incorporated? 166.248.74.12 (talk) 20:26, November 14, 2011 (UTC)
 * Earth is still associated primarily with density, not speed. Omnibender - Talk - Contributions 21:07, November 14, 2011 (UTC)

Fire+Lighting = Flash/Swift Release --Elveonora (talk) 21:53, November 14, 2011 (UTC)
 * That combination is more appropriate for Explosion Release. Omnibender - Talk - Contributions 22:00, November 14, 2011 (UTC)

I think Explosion is Lighting+Wind. Fire can't make Lighting explode. --Elveonora (talk) 23:15, November 14, 2011 (UTC)
 * Fire and lightning both create explosions. Omnibender - Talk - Contributions 23:30, November 14, 2011 (UTC)

Not really. Fire can't explode and lighting neither ... unless you have a proof or something. --Elveonora (talk) 23:38, November 14, 2011 (UTC)
 * Lightning hits stuff, the energy in it passes to what was hit. Thunder is basically the air exploding due to rapid expansion. Fire doesn't explode everything, but if you throw fire into anything flammable, you'll get an explosion. Omnibender - Talk - Contributions 23:45, November 14, 2011 (UTC)

But that's not reason for explosion. I think it's Lighting + Wind. Pure Oxigen is highly explosive. Lighting Release is basically super vibrating electrons. Electrons can't explode by themselves. Adding heat thus Fire Release would just make them move faster, generating even more heat. But hitting someone with Lighting Release makes friction, thus sparks. Sparks will detonate the oxygen in the Wind Release ... Boom! --Elveonora (talk) 01:01, November 15, 2011 (UTC)

Comet Release
Since you are redoing the Fire + Earth + Yang combo what about instead Comet Release it serves a similar purpose only with a better connection to earth and fire. Comet appear as a glowing mass of of rock that burns as it travels. Its basically a rock who burns a bright whit/blue. There you go this element creates a rock made of rock and flame whose color and intensely is changed by Yang. Correct me if I am wrong but doesn't fire turn blue when it burns brighter? After all Madara meteor was just a giant rock that smashes the field.Umishiru (talk) 17:29, November 15, 2011 (UTC)