Board Thread:Theories and Speculation/@comment-36019309-20190114073523/@comment-9782468-20190125202359

Ninja Of War wrote: @James

Found a similar post (not the one I was looking for). From MIGshiobi

"@Asian my argument isnt that an uchiha cant break the tsyukyomi. Its rather that they don't have the time to, in the same way gyuki doesn't have the time to break bee out of tsyukyomi if its cast with massive time dilation to make the injury a fatal coma in one second of time. The reason I stated the argument was relevant to the other thread is because Slap happy ( the OP of that thread who is fortunately here now as well) came to the conclusion that based off your theory, since minato and kurama have a symbiotic partnership, kyuubi inside minato during tsyukyomi would be able to release him in 1/72 of a second if in tsyukyomi he theoretically released him an hour in." God I remember my arguments with him. Lol.

Countering the argument again though.

The elite Uchiha is the only one who is able to break Tsukuyomi, and this Uchiha could do it while under the effects of time dilation.

One of the reasons is that the caster is also in the Genjutsu too, actively torturing. We know this because the caster has conversations with the victim, which wouldn't be possible if Tsukuyomi was just a precoded signal (which MlGShinobi argued it was).

My theory doesn't say that a Jinjuuriki could break out of Tsukuyomi because of their symbiotic relationship. Quite the contrary, I believe that if Naruto for example was caught, neither he nor Kurama could save him. The reason is that Kurama wouldn't be experiencing the Genjutsu as well. Therefore for Kurama, Tsukuyomi would still be over in a second, whereas for Naruto, he was tortured for however long.

Basically, nothing proves that an elite Uchiha can't break out of Tsukuyomi. Jinjuuriki and partner methods don't work simply because a partner or a Tailed Beast wouldn't be able to break you out in less than a second before the damage is done. The only way they could break out is if they were a highly skilled Uchiha.