Board Thread:Wiki Discussions/@comment-1251315-20141009193453/@comment-1251315-20141013112731

Like I said before, setup a set of topics for each candidate so everyone can say whether they support it, oppose it, or are neutral, and give a rationale or reason why they think the user is or isn't a fit. Like it's been mentioned previously, those topics start massive flame wars and are just going to be a source of biased support/oppose. People would just support their friends and oppose people they didn't like, even if the people they didn't like were perfectly capable candidates.

It would not work and would result in more acrimony between users.

Honestly, we've gone beyond the need for discussion, previous discussions have turned into huge flame wars and have never led anywhere meaningful, they would only turn into threads where haters can vent their hate against the candidates just for the sake of hating, there would be more bias than ever in separate threads.