Board Thread:Theories and Speculation/@comment-45273751-20200322060033/@comment-39350828-20200411033115

CyberianGinseng wrote: Babyfriend1 wrote: In this case you could say the "missing chakra" is all the chakra black zetsu had to combine to recreate kaguya's chakra

The chakra of hyuga clan members was used to recreate kaguya. That's why infinite tsukuyomi had to be done before black zetsu could do his betrayal but no kaguya clan members were alive at the time of infinite tsukuyomi so apparently their chakra is not a constituent of all-killing ash bones

Yeah I never denied that shikotsumyaku comes from all-killing ash bones. I was saying that it seems like shitotsumyaku doesn't seem like just all-killing ash bones minus something Was every chakra present at Kaguya's rebirth supposed to be essential, even people who were not Ninjas? That makes the non ninja Damiyo we saw get assimilated an integral part of Kaguya but Kaguya clan isn't? So the the Damiyo is a component of AKAB, but Kaguya clan isn't? Clearly not. Just the presence of some chakra during her rebirth doesn't mean it had any relation to ANY of her jutsu.

Black Zetsu stated that Infinite Tsukuyomi would reassemble "a large amount of the chakra that had been scattered in this world," to recreate Kaguya. No other clan was singled out as essential to Kaguya being reformed. The Hyuuga were irrelevant. Only the quantity of chakra was ever stated by anybody to be needed.

The equation is simple: Senju + Uchiha = Rinnegan. Rinnegan + Juubi = Juubi jinchuuriki = Infinite Tsukuyomi. Juubi Jinchuuriki + "a large amount (not type) of chakra" + Black Zetsu = Kaguya.

All-Killing Ash Bones is a derivative of Kaguya's bone manipulating ability, not a derivative of that "large amount of chakra" that Black Zetsu assembled This was stated in the databook. That is not in dispute.

All-Killing Ash Bones is a particular jutsu created from this unnamed ability to manipulate her bones. We don't know what it consists of, except that it's derived from Kaguya's bone manipulating ability, just as Shitotsumyaku and all of its techniques are derived from her bone manipulating ability. Therefore it is necessarily a component of Kaguya by that fact that it CAME from her alone. Okay I retract "all the chakra" being the ingredients for all-killing ash bones. BZ stating that a large amount of the chakra that had been scattered in the world was necessary doesn't mean there weren't specific pieces of chakra that had been scattered that were essential. For example if I said "a cake requires many ingredients" I only specify the quantity of ingredients needed and yet you don't assume that that means having a lot of random ingredients will help you meet that requirement. Why do you think it had to be specified that the required chakra had to be the chakra that had been scattered in the world ie the chakra that originated from kaguya as opposed to chakra from the otsutsuki living on the moon or from the tenseigan or god trees on other planets or a new god tree on earth or any other source? If anything, black zetsu's statement confirms that not just any chakra will work. All-killing ash bones isn't the bone-manipulating ability kaguya has but a derivative of it? (separate question) Are you saying shikotsumyaku is a component of kaguya?