Board Thread:Versus Debates/@comment-31568508-20170504124507/@comment-30426414-20170512215849

Madara would still win. The five kage got 3 lethal hits on Madara. The first was when Ohnoki hit him with the particle to clear away the poison. By Madara's own admission, he only let that hit him to reveal Hashirama's face on his chest. He wouldn't need to do that in this situation since he can't afford to and he doesn't have Hashirama's cells.

The second time Madara got hit was when Tsunade crushed him, but that was a wood clone.

The third time was after Oonoki's Tsunade enhanced particle style that took Madara's arm and leg. I can't really see him escaping that unharmed but thats not enough to take out Madara. When he came back to life in the war, the bijuu severed his arm as well but he was fine. Now after loosing his arm and leg, Madara's only option would be to fight with Susanoo. Knowing he can't afford to play around anymore due to his injuries, he would use perfect susanoo to end it quickly.