Board Thread:Theories and Speculation/@comment-9782468-20160223232833/@comment-27660682-20160227064815

Because I already explained why thats physically ly impossible. If itachi made him experience 72 hours of getting his eye ripped out in an INSANT, he doesnt have the time to break the genjutsu. You cant react to something that happens instantly, reread the manga panel I showed you in itachi vs kakashi in part one. The fact that a third party, zetsu, was still able to react to events going on in the illusion means it wasn't instantly cast. If it was instant then he wouldnt have been able to react, asuma said kakaahi instantly fell to the ground, where as black zetsu was reacting to sasuke getting his eye ripped put, then reacted when sasuke broke it. Since two events were reacted to by a third party, that means itachi didnt cast it to make its effects as instant.Maybe the time dilation could have been 1 second:15 minutes for all we know, and 15 minutes of trauma isnt enough to put anyone in a coma in most cases just look at other examples of genjustu in the series. But 1 to 72 HOURS? Thats a big difference, and that was good enough to put kakashi in a coma for a week. The time dilation clearly makes the difference as no other genjutsu has put someone in a coma for that long, and kakashi even admitted the illusion was so strong that itachi could have just killed him but didnt. You have to remember that advanced genjustu tricks the body into feeling real physical pain, so he made kakashi feel he was being stabbed by swords for 72 hours. You think you wouldn't be in a coma if you felt that? My argument is simple, I understand everything else you are saying, however the itachi vs sasuke fight has an infinite amount of possible time dilation s, I just know for a fact that the dilation wasnt significant enough to make sasuke fall into a coma, and it also wasnt significant enough because he was able to break it, meaning  he had the time to break it. So a possible dilation could have been 1 second= 15 secondsfor sasuke. And in the real world maybe 2 minutes passed which would equal 30 minutes for sasuke. And that still fulfills my proof

Jiraiya told naruto that the reason genjustu is hard for most people to do is because you need to have the skill and intelligence to create a convincing illusion. So itachi did just that, he made kakashi feel he was really being stabbed and taunted by itachi for 3 days, and he messed with kakashi's five senses to make his nervous system create the pain in his real body, all in an instant. If itachi didnt stab him, then kakashi would have felt little to no relative trauma at all, he just would have seen himself pinned to a cross for 3 days, thats nothing.