Board Thread:Versus Debates/@comment-28381997-20160509220110/@comment-25558176-20160511195036

Lulcielid wrote: Are we doing Eye vs Eye or Eye User vs Eye User? I think we are mixing both.

EDIT: OP is unclear which one of the two is asking. Pretty much this; It would be wrong to do Eye vs Eye, when the eye ability is all dependent on the person using it. Example; Kakashi vs Obito Genjutsu match Kakashi, who isn't an Uchiha managed to spar with Obito using only genjutsu to a standstill. Would he be able to do this during part 1? No, because he didn't have much experience with his transplanted sharingan eye. Same goes for these two rinnegan and tenseigan users. It all comes down to how capable the user is with his eye jutsu, not necessarily how capable the eye is.

I'd say both eyes are evenly matched, and it all depends on the eye user whether the rinnegan or the tenseigan comes out on top in a match.