Board Thread:Versus Debates/@comment-30966312-20180413200754/@comment-30966312-20180818174223

Soloking itachi15 wrote: JohnCenaNation wrote: JOA20 wrote: JohnCenaNation wrote: Actually, you do need the moon to cast Mugen Tsukuyomi as shown by both Kaguya and Madara. Rinne Sharingan isn't enough. Kaguya used the moon only in the anime, in the manga it's unknown how she cast IT. As I see it, the moon is required only to cast IT on a global scale, while eye contact is enough to use it on individuals. There was no moon in Kaguya's time, how could she cast IT without it? The anime did a very poor filler of Kaguya's backstory, I'd rather forget about it.

To cast a genjutsu of this scale, the user's Rinne Sharingan must be reflected off of the moon.

Sorry pal, but that's not how the jutsu works. Only for a single individual the rinnesharingan is enough. The moon is a reflector, it reflects the rinnesharingan and cast the mugen tsukyoumi on the planet.You don't need the damn moon just to put a individual in mugen tsukyoumi. If Naruto left the battlefield and tried to gain distance ,then kaguya can launch the mugen tsukyoumi from the moon and capture him at any part of the planet.

Yes, you need the damn moon dumbass, it was stated in the fricking manga by Madara, Kaguya even had to summon a moon from her dimension to use Mugen Tsukuyomi as well, unless you can provide me evidence where you can use Mugen Tsukuyomi without the damn moon, you can shut up with your headcanon.