Board Thread:Naruto Discussions/@comment-36221354-20180717114536/@comment-6769189-20180802063950

Nightguy76 wrote:

Obito wasn't a reincarnate. Ten tail's chakra isn't the other half of Hagoromo's chakra, only fragments of it put together as one. It does sound more reasonable to have both eyes present to unlock it though right? Like, each of your own eyes. MS doesnt need both eyes.

Either way, it was never stated or shown that both were needed. The appropriate eye just needs to be exposed to exposed to the appropriate chakra.

Nightguy76 wrote:

I remember Hagoromo telling Naruto that Madara was no longer Indra's reincarnate. Probably because he became the Ten tail's Jinchuriki. Mehh, who knows. So why didn't Sasuke get two Rinnegan then? Who was an actual reincarnate. He wasnt the lastest reincarnate but he's still a reincarnate and he doesnt lose whatever parts of Indras chakra he had.

He also never said Madara stopped being a reincarnation.

Nightguy76 wrote:

I am pretty sure he did. Filler only and filler is non-canon.

Nightguy76 wrote:

Okay you stumped me on this one. But he's had his share of God tree chakra fruits and pills bruh. Surely you'd think.... Momoshiki was never to have eaten from the tree. He has only ever used the food pills. Considering they are in his hands he could have gotten them from someone else but even then the only way to get a Rinnegan that the series has shown us is to inherit them from someone who has a Rinnesharingan.