Board Thread:Naruto Discussions/@comment-26508646-20150704031517/@comment-25549954-20150714181010

LegionZero wrote: Niether Naruto nor Kurama had any of the tailed beasts chakra at that time. Tailed Beasts can communucate telepathically'''. Bee said it plain as day he didn't say because of chakra. He said they can speak mind to mind.''' Tailed beasts cant communicate with humans telepathically, but if they speak telepathically to another beast, the jinchuriki can hear it if they are at that level of consciousness at the time. The 8 Tails asked if NARUTO could hear the 5 tails. Not "hey Naruto, Guy and Kakashi do you hear that?" Because Naruto, having the 9 tails, is the only other person who COULD hear him. Son said Naruto was speaking to him in his mind because Kurama was inside him and explicitly said he refused to give him ANY power. Then LATER, gave him chakra. Then later he went deeper because his link with Kurama was stronger. This is stated outright. Not because Kurama had chakra from anuone else. At that point Naruto had Kurama and Sons chakra and AFTER speaking to Naruto theygave him chakra.

Then Naruto didn't get 8 or 1 Tails chakra untill Obito gave it to him.

The beasts dont have Mind Transfer or use chakra for subconscious communication. The latter is your assumption that is displayed otherwise multiple times and the former is outright made up. @Legion-I believe Hagoromo is right and what he said is true. Hagoromo said that Naruto has the "chakra" of all tailed beast, he is the meting point, they can talk among themselves there. There is no other meaning to this, it is very clear. Every time a person appears in subconscious they'll appear only because of chakra, and there are multiple example of this, for example- When Naruto and Sasuke clashed with their Rasengan and Chidori they spoke in subconscious mind, momentarily to communicate, convey message, feelings, etc., Kushina and Minato appeared when the seal was opened because they transferred some of their chakra in Naruto. Dan appearing in Tsunade, Obito and Naruto conversation etc.

Tailed Beasts chakra is bound to this world, when they die with the Jinchuriki they'll come back again, their chakra will regenerate it is not like Kushina, Minato, they can regenerate their chakra, because they are chakra monster.

Bee said that they can communicate telepathically and it is rare and interesting event, alluding that it has never happened before and he already knows they are speaking telepathically but that's just my opinion. Gyuki and Naruto communicated telepathically to Naruto only after Killer B fist bumped Naruto in ch 565, and that is why Kurama and Gyuki communicated telepathically, so their Jinchurikis could also hear them. The fist bump was made with B, just for communication, it was not made with Gyuki, it was not much of a chakra transfer, so Gyuki didn't give him chakra the other beasts did by doing fistbump. Naruto was already in that meeting place thanks to Kurama, so Kurama has connection to tailed beasts that is what Son told Naruto, after he linked with Kurama fully and after touching the receiver he was brought to the meeting place which connected every beast thanks to Kurama. Now Naruto can also come to this place if he wants voluntarily, they gave their chakra later as a gift so it may help Naruto and also for future communication, Son believed that he is the person who will unite all the beast once again. If they communicate telepathically then why the talk of uniting them once again. They can communicate telepathically or in subconscious if they are linked either by fistbump or the demonic statue chains, basically chakra. 5 tails example is the only example deviating from this, I assume that when 5 tails hurted 8 tails that is when they momentarily linked with each other, if the beasts are linked their Jinchurikis can hear them.

And about the mind transfer it wasn't made up I gave you an example that Naruto never spoke to Gyuki telepathically before, when Naruto contacted the intel division while fighting third Raikage, they made communication with B and Gyuki spoke to Naruto.

Its implied Naruto was talking to Hagoromo before getting the 8 and 1 tails chakra because they show up near the end of the conversation. He most likely spoke to Naruto because he was about to die. Obito transferred it already, the other beasts were present there already, it is just that they chose to appear in front of Hagoromo after their conversation.