Board Thread:Theories and Speculation/@comment-44142243-20200416151624/@comment-4961229-20200418013932

I'm just waiting for one of those folks to make an appearance, who believe Itachi found SoT and YM in a cave somewhere and stuck them in his eyeballs somehow, because Itachi, and somehow that's why Sasuke can't use them, because Itachi. BeyondRed wrote: The series arguably doesn't actually explain how the Mangekyō works aside from how to awaken it and the requirement for using Susanoo. For example, there isn't even any dialogue that says "each eye gains a single technique that's different for each person", it's just something we've picked up on through observation. Sort of like how people now theorize that each set of Rinnegan grants a unique ability to their owner, but there's less evidence to go off of for that. Back in the day, it was actually common belief among fans that every pair of Mangekyō could automatically use Tsukuyomi and Amaterasu, whereas techniques like Kakashi's Kamui had to be gained through training, but that obviously didn't turn out to be right.

That said, I think Tobirama's explanation of how the (regular) Sharingan awakens in chapter 619 gives us a pretty good indication of how this all works: under certain circumstances, the Uchiha's brain releases special chakra that permanently transforms the eye, even if it's later removed from their head. Awakening the Mangekyō is likely caused by a similar reaction, so it would make sense that creating the EMS works the same way, effectively "overwriting" the eye's existing properties with new brain chakra, while still retaining its "ocular power" (indicated by the two patterns overlapping).

The real question is whether an Uchiha could awaken a new set of Sharingan or Mangekyō by transplanting another's eyes, or if each stage of activation can only happen once per person. Sounds reasonable. Any ideas why brothers couldn't simply swap Mangekyous and both acquire EMS? Other than plot, of course.

Also, no one has ever addressed that I've heard whether or not Genjutsu could exclusively be used to trigger the effect without actually killing anyone. Why wouldn't every father drag their sons into the woods and Genjutsu them into believing their most loved people had been killed right in front of them? Why wouldn't their brains release the chakra? Surely the genes governing all this aren't somehow monitoring whether or not all this is truly happening or figment of someone's jutsu?

Obviously, the real reason is plot demands that this not happen, otherwise, every Uchiha and their mama's mama would be running around with Mangekyou. I'm just after the in universe reason.