Board Thread:Wiki Discussions/@comment-3238846-20140422105553/@comment-24868607-20140427133405

@Mercurious you've literally reiterated what i said, which is that KG due to transplants orginate from the transplanted parts themselves.

"Naruto can get ONLY Youton chakra from the Son Goku inside of him and use it that's why he should be listed as a Lava"

From a logical point of view this is absurd. If the following is acceptable:

Son produces & mixes -> Lava (fire + earth) -> Naruto uses

Why is the following unacceptable?

Son produces -> fire -> Naruto uses

Son produces -> earth -> Naruto uses

or even: Bijuu produces -> element X -> Naruto uses

Because you haven't seen it?! That excuse simply doesn't stand especially as you make exceptions for other characters. Take Obito

H-cells produce and mix -> Wood -> Obito uses <=> valid

H-cells produce -> Water -> Obito uses <=> valid yet not seen

H-cells produce -> earth -> Obito uses <=> valid yet not seen

As similiarly said before is like saying goku who has both a mouse and elephant can hand naruto a elephant but not the mouse. Or i can send you a bacon sandwich but I cannot send you the bread or bacon seperately etc. K & Y clearly stated that mixing two elements gives you a new element (KG) the hand signs and the "how" is another issue which is possibly relevant.

Also something to note is he has been given a portion / avatar etc of the beasts so to label it entirely as a tailed beast skill at least to the extent of a full blown jinjuriki is questionable.