Board Thread:Versus Debates/@comment-26005711-20150530210611/@comment-25857684-20150602102727

Not only was Madara dead at that point of time, that shadowy figure had a right sharingan, and Madara only had a left sharingan after he transplanted his Rinnegan into Nagato.

What gives you the impression that Madara was dead at that time?. There's no indication regarding this. The meeting between Kisame and Yagura could have taken place even before the third Shinobi war. Remember ... Sharingan eyes could be transferred hence he could have replaced his right eye with another sharingan. We have no bloody clue whatsoever in regards to the timeline. I'm only assuming that the shadow which clearly is the same outline of Uchiha Madara is Uchiha Madara himself.