Board Thread:Theories and Speculation/@comment-1512913-20161115123051/@comment-1512913-20161119181533

Well, I'm not going to remove Magnet being Earth and Wind from the wiki or even think about it, just saying it can be questioned because of the book's quality or lack thereof and because the amount of sources being 1. The more evidence there is to something being true, the more likely it is to in fact be true, but with just one picture as the sole evidence in a book filled with glaring mistakes, excuse my skepticism.

And the biggest problem with the 4th databook is nitpicking. 'It's true that Rinnegan is Kekkei Mora because Hagoromo has Kekkei Mora in his profile!!!!' everyone takes what they like and disregard the rest, so how can it be used as a factual source for the wiki? I think we should have completely ignored the nature sheets anyway. Example being Hashirama's lack of Yin Release in the book despite usage of Genjutsu in the manga, even though we factually state that Genjutsu = Yin Release here on the wiki, so the only way to go around that was to disregard the book and say it's an error in that case.

If we take it that Genjutsu is 100% certain to be Yin Release, then it surely is an error... but are we? well we say so. But if we were to state that we are not certain if all Genjutsu is Yin Release, then Hashirama's exclusion of Yin might not be an error. And if lack of Yin for Hashirama might not be an error even though he used Genjutsu because not all Genjutsu may be Yin, then I can say that Rasa having Water Release can potentially be an error and it was in fact supposed to be Lightning instead of Water thus Magnet can be Wind + Lightning.

EDOT: my point is that this wiki should make clear about the things we are sure about and things we are not so sure about and we shouldn't pretend that we are.