Board Thread:Theories and Speculation/@comment-36019309-20190114073523/@comment-9782468-20190204074749

FlatZone wrote: You all are arguing what ifs. That's not debating. Naruto told B if he was caught in Tsukuyomi it was over, regardless of him being a Perfect Jinchuriki and that was during the 4th Ninja World War. The Databooks say that only an extremely skilled Uchiha with a very powerful Sharingan has a chance of breaking out of Tsukuyomi. It never said they would escape unharmed or not weakened. Okay first off, of course a Perfect Jinjuuriki can't break out. It's the same reason the partner method doesn't work; the Tailed Beast is outside the Genjutsu, so the damage is done before the Tailed Beast can free the Jinjuuriki. The one who breaks it has to be the one experiencing it, and only an extremely skilled Uchiha can at all.

And secondly, you're saying everyone is arguing "what-ifs." Well that's exactly what you're doing when you say things like "It never said they would escape unharmed or not weakened." That kind of logic doesn't work in debates. Otherwise, I can say "Nothing ever said Kakashi can't use Susanoo anymore because you don't need eyes to use it." or "Itachi knows how to use Izanagi." You can't just say No one ever said it wasn't something, so therefore it is something.