Board Thread:Theories and Speculation/@comment-45444155-20200715142058/@comment-45444155-20200717095933

LegionZero wrote: ReweR 1331 wrote:

No, I'm not telling you it's a different chakra. I'm just talking about how it's obtained. Madara got it from his, and Sasuke got it from outside, from Hagoromo. It's like the fruit of the chakra, someone gets Rinnegan at once, and someone, because of genetic predisposition, develops it himself. It's still the same thing though. Whether one recreates Hagoromo's chakra or gets it from Hagoromo, they will have both aspects of his chakra. Neither method affords the reciever benefits that other doesnt.

ReweR 1331 wrote:

Sasuke already has a ready chakra that gives him Rinnegan, because he can activate Sharingan, Byakugan with him. Sasuke didnt get the Rinnegan from the chakra. He got it from Hagoromo. If he fot ir from just the chakra, it would have been a standard pair of Rinnegan.

Not sure why you are talking about Byakugan

ReweR 1331 wrote:

Rinnegan Madara is the result of changing his chakra, not introducing a ready-made chakra into his system like Sasuke. It's obvious to everyone, it's elementary. Sasuke's chakra changed too...

ReweR 1331 wrote:

Yeah, what's wrong with that? I also use jardic. .... what?

ReweR 1331 wrote:

Madara clearly says the Sasuke has one Rinnegan. Exactly noted that one of the two / of the pair. This indicates that 1 Rinnegan Sasuke = 1 Rinnegan Madara, but 1 Rinnegan Sasuke ≠ 2 Rinnegan Madara. Madara could just say that Sasuke awakened Rinnegan, but no, he noted that Sasuke awakened one Rinnegan of two. Mmmm no. What chapter is this supposedly from? I dont remember any interpretations like what you are describing

ReweR 1331 wrote:

Yes, I agree with you here, even if he gave the Yin chakra, that chakra still carries spiritual and physical energy. Then he is still getting the physical energy that would be carried by Ashura's chakra. Its the same Hagoromo chakra.

Rinnegan's just getting it from the 6P chakra now? Hagoromo gave Rinnegan the Sasuke through the chakra and not just for nothing, you're wearing the Sasuke with that eye. It's a white eye joke.

Yes, it's changed, but it's different ways of changing. Madara created Rinnegan from his chakra (or at least part of his, Indra's chakra) when Sasuke just got it from the outside. His chakra Indra did nothing, unlike Madara.

Tom 70. Chapter 673. Do not ignore what Madara said one of the two / one of the pair. There's only one interpretation - Sasuke has half the power of Rinna.

Yes, he also gets physical energy from Hagoromo / Ashura. But the main aspect of the Yin chakra is spiritual energy. It's supposed to be because of Yin that Sasuke has one Rinnegan. Had Sasuke Yang chakra SP he would have gotten Rinnegan in his right eye, probably. Get the Sasuke chakra SP, he'd have Rinnegan in both eyes. Something like that.

I really don't quite see how that affects Ashura. So he doesn't lose anything, he doesn't care if he gets the chakra SP, the chakra Yin SP or the chakra Yang SP.

I don't understand why you have to make up that Hagoromo is God and can do what he wants when you can prove it with the data you already have.