Board Thread:Theories and Speculation/@comment-12509038-20150119062617/@comment-26112212-20150121222101

@Kirin- I really enjoyed this story (a million kudos to you for your creativity) I hope this awesome story is animated, I really don't mind even if the animators decide to make a filler arc about this story because there are many story Kishimoto didn’t explain may be he felt it was unnecessary and in many ways it wasn’t related to Naruto’s story like fore.g. Hashirama and Tobirama’s death. Kaguya's origin is what intrigues me the most and was not explained clearly in manga, her intentions were not clear, her mixed feelings, her desire to protect earth and at the same time to turn everyone into White Zetsu Army it didn't make sense in manga until you explained it and it makes more sense, it fits perfectly into stories of two brothers Hagoromo and Hamura.

I've also thought of a similar story but it's slightly different I’m not good when it comes to narration I could have made another thread but oh well this seems kinda similar so I decided to post it here, (basically my version of Kaguya is an alien who came to earth by space pod or something and tree is using her) it's not that interesting as your story but anyway here I go.

Kaguya was a princess on another planet, she fell in love with a lower class citizen and he loved her too and so they both decided to marry each other but her father did not agree, he had already hired her a prince, he thought this person was not worthy and all clansmen agreed upon their King's decision it was like taboo to marry lower class, and the princess should marry only with family of kings and queens in Otsutsuki ‘s planet, she decided to go against her father and leave this kingdom and planet and live a peaceful life elsewhere with her lover, and so she found earth, in her home planet her clansmen decided to track down that person who escaped with her on Kings order because she went against her father’s decision they decided to wage war with any planet and kill that man who ran away with her, she already knew that they would come looking for her and few months have passed she came to know about Shinju tree which gives immense power she thought she could harness its power for protecting her loved ones, but before she could get pass to eat Shinju's fruit, an old monk (guardian) near the tree warns her not to trespass and tells her not to consume the fruit even if the tree tells her to (and yeah here the tree speaks its purpose is to spread the seeds of the fruit) and he tells her the story of this tree, it grew by drinking the blood of the deceased on the battlefield and bore a chakra fruit. She didn't understand what the monk exactly meant, she couldn't eat. After interacting with humans Kaguya became Rabbit Goddess, people began worshipping only for her appearance, she became a leader like figure. One day her lover was killed by her clansmen army then she and her fellow humans decide to battle with them, and her clansmen ask her to come to her planet and she'll be forgiven but she rejects that offer and retaliates, angered by her actions the King sends more army and she hides and watches all the human die, she goes to old monk and tells that she needs to protect her folks so the monk allows her to eat the fruit but warns that she would be consumed by feelings of hatred, before eating the fruit she had to let go all the feelings attachments(Kind of a reference to Avatar series) but she ate the fruit anyway and she used its power and defeated some of her Otsutsuki clansmen and because she lost her loved ones her hatred grew more, but she could suppress her uncontrollable feeling/ emotions, after some months Kaguy gave birth to Hagoromo and Hamura and after many years they had children,  Kaguya was vulnerable and always felt the loss, the tree controlled her brain consciousness to make another fruit and the tree says that in return she would have the army to fight for her revenge, (from the point in manga that she considered earth as a nursery I guess she hated war and to stop wars between humans and Otsutsukis’) she merged with Shinju.. And you know what happens next, Kaguya uses her Rinne Sharingan and enslaves the people, but Hagoromo frees them, she explains him that the power is overwhelming and she cannot control herself, Hagoromo then decides to make Ninshu to control oneself and also use chakra for peaceful purpose by sharing, but Kaguya couldn't control herself she experiments with her power away from Hagoromo, she creates Black Zetsu and it knows her ability to create dimensions, and she thinks to revive her love but she couldn’t as her chakra was distributed to her sons. After some days the tree takes full control over her and it wants new chakra fruit badly.

Hagoromo and Hamura already knew about their mother abusing her powers, she showed signs of losing herself, and great pride was consuming her so they were ready for anything, so they started to make sealing tools (Treasured Tool of Sage of Six Paths). After few days they couldn’t find her mother; they thought she has gone to her planet. They found some people were trapped in Infinite Tsukuyomi they tried to free some of them but they couldn’t. They found that Shinju tree is after their mother for using it's chakra and it was the tree’s doing and only way to free the people is to fight it so they decided to fight against it unbeknownst to them that they are actually fighting against their mother, the tree is after two of them as it had remnants of its chakra they fought in different dimensions just like Naruto and Sasuke however Hagoromo summoned Hamura who was trapped in another dimension they used those tools but those were of no use and so they decided to seal Ten-Tails with their ultimate sealing technique Six Paths Chibaku Tensei but leaves Black Zetsu behind...The end for Kaguya’s origin, let me know if you like it?

@LeoWorld456- Gemnist answered your question but really we can't say much about how they started relations in the first place, there were many clans during era of warring states mainly Hagoromo clan, Senju clan, Uchiha clan, Kurama clan etc. My theory: Uzumaki clan (mix of Indra's descendants + Asura's descendants) could have descended from Indra Otsutsuki don't take it seriously I'm just saying because Indra's Mangekyou symbol looks like the clan's symbol and some of Asura clan members could have decided to join with them and Asura clan named themselves Uzumaki clan they loved peace and so they liked to join others and so became relative of Senju may be. :D

@Gemnist: Really Indra copying Byakugan abilities, Asura doing the same thing, Hamura double agent lol :D, but really some things made sense and some things didn't :D no offence I liked your stories even the film one, you have made a good point about two reincarnations being in different bodies at the same time. No explanation can be given about that but we can just accept it as it is.

If you go by Avatar series even the soul of first Avatar had a purpose so it kept reincarnating until the purpose was fulfilled and similar thing is in Naruto verse I think there is no purpose for Indra and Asura now aside from spreading Ninshu and really they have attained realization so they should go to pure world after death of Naruto and Sasuke, the cycle of reincarnation in earth realm is over, they’ll not fight again. The cycle will continue again from the pure world back to earth, but it will be for other purpose. Great story Kirin, Thanks :D