Board Thread:Theories and Speculation/@comment-30168130-20161223235115/@comment-734582-20161227115631

Lorenzo.r.1st wrote: 1- soul or not man, he gave chakra to them cuz he himself said so. if u want some proof ill look something up. I think you're misunderstanding my intent. Hagoromo possessed Naruto and Sasuke as a spirit. That means that under the rules of Edo Tensei, he can grant them chakra, his powers, etc.

Lorenzo.r.1st wrote: 2-i think that the bijuu-nature chakra thing is just plot at the moment, but that may as well change. and since Naruto sensed a different chakra from the juubi than the bijuu themselves, means that hago had to mess with the juubi a little more than a bit to make the bijuu themselves If splitting the biju was easy, he'd have done it long before the end of his life, and he wouldn't have taken a great risk with the Gedo Statue.

Lorenzo.r.1st wrote: -if the host from the edo jutsu are messed with, it doent matter, cuz the soul will make it look like how the soul was at its prime, and since the body heals to always look the same way again, then messing with the bodies is impossible... Judging from 1st and 2nd hokage vs the 3rd, the Edo Tensei user choses the appearance of the Edo Tensei. It's not an automatic power of the edo tensei.

Lorenzo.r.1st wrote: 4-i said that lee couldn't use it, and not that he didn't have it.. read it twice next time bro.. and what I said is: A-that u need a soul to make the body work and mind work, which when working together makes chakra. B-u need a body to have a mind, and so no body, no chakra and no mind, which means no soul.. C-no mind means no physical control over body, so that makes a useless soul trapped in a useless body, and no body to work with mind means no chakra either.. D-no chakra either means body and mind are unstable and/or unable to work together, that a stable soul is lacking to control both body and mind, or that either the mind or body might be defective in some way.. I don't understand the point you're trying to make. But it's pretty clear that a soul can think, so you don't need a body to have a mind.