Board Thread:Versus Debates/@comment-26998824-20151210004253/@comment-28869806-20151210204620

reasons why Itachi wins:

1) Superior Ninjutsu: Tobirama may have more supposedly but none of them can counter susanoo.

2) superior reflexes: Tobirama may be faster but that's only because of FTG (without it he's nowhere near as fast as Itachi.) and even then Minato does it better and even with Minato's skill with the technique it wouldn't make much of a difference.

3) Sharingan: Tobirama may have experience with fighting the Sharingan but I'm speaking more about the ability to read movement which is a huge advantage.

4) superior intelligence: yes Tobirama is smart, but Itachi is much smarter.

5) superior physical strength: Tobirama hasn't shown the much physical strength, whereas Itachi was able to create a crater in the wall of a building just by kicking Sasuke into it even though he's was terminally ill at the time, his physical strength would be drastically superior without the disease.

6) Susanoo: Tobirama hasn't shown a single technique that can counter this, and if we include Itachi's perfect Susanoo than Tobirama is screwed. (yes I know it's game only, but we use Shisui's susanoo in versus debates and that was also game only.)

7) Genjutsu: Itachi is one of the greatest Genjutsu users in this series, Tobirama has nothing on him.

in conclusion Tobirama doesn't stand a chance.