Board Thread:Wiki Discussions and Support/@comment-142748-20141231093731/@comment-1207741-20150102014343

SuperSaiyaMan wrote: Then why did no one collaborate on Obito's account? Everyone else who was involved is dead?

Heck why did Kakashi even want to investigate to see if it was true to confirm Obito's account? To see if it was true, no? And it was.

Itachi's flashbacks were of him in the ANBU, not five years old. I know, and that was my point. The relocation would have already occurred by the time of his flashbacks.

He would have seen and experienced any discrimination or segregation, wouldn't he? Yet the manga put the blame for what happened to the Uchiha...solely on the Uchiha. Shisui and Itachi never, ever mentioned 'And now the Uchiha have a curfew' or 'Despite loving the village, our own clan is suffering'. Not even a handwave. Not all discrimination is as overt as you make it out to be. If the Uchiha are denied opportunities simply because of their clan, that's discrimination. You don't need to be insulted in the street or denied food to suffer.

And Sasuke, at 7, would still have seen his Clan being treated differently wouldn't they Snapper? I would remind you that Sasuke was completely unaware of the coup at all, so him not noticing things is hardly evidence.

Since a villain said it. One which lied straight to Sasuke's face about not being involved with the Kurama attack on Konoha. If say Hiruzen said it, it wouldn't be in question. But Obito, who lied to Sasuke's face...why wouldn't he lie to Sasuke to get him on his side about the Uchiha's motives? Again, that's fine reasoning for a forum. But the wiki cannot pick and choose what it regards as truth simply because a character lied about other topics. The most it can do is say, "According to Obito...". It cannot take the extra step to say, "Obito lied about..." without direct evidence of the lie.

People who are forcibly relocated aren't usually given already built buildings. They are forced to live on new ground. The Uchiha had no evidence of that. The Nazis' Jewish gehttos were not new buildings.

The series is not obligated to be consistent with real world practices.

Heck, when Sasuke turned to his side...he got a VERY happy smirk. I'm pretty sure the mask prevents smirking.

Since an author's job is 'Show, don't Tell'. If Kishimoto never showed it, it should be taken with a grain of salt. Kishimoto hasn't shown Minato and Kushina getting married, either. Is that a lie since it was never seen?