Board Thread:Naruto Discussions/@comment-25124448-20140630200132/@comment-24874466-20140701015617

Skoob617 wrote: No it did not. Hinata was able to repel that because she was draped in Naruto's Kyubi chakra. Madara even stated that she had become powerful after she recieved the Kyubi chakra. I still believe that the Uchiha would win. I think the only reason the Hyuga are known as the strongest in the village is because the Uchiha were chased out and exterminated. As I said before, the strongest (not all) attacks of the Hyuga are short-ranged attacks. Most of the Uchiha have enough power to be able to get some distance between them and their foe(s) and use some fire techniques. Remember, only the best non-branch family members even knew the Kaiten. Especially now, when the Branch members still were not permitted to learn half of their most powerful jutsu.
 * hakke kuusho and hakke kuhekisho which was also strong enough to single handily deflect the Juubi's tail before the Naruto cloak chakra boost

When I made my first comment, I was refering to the overall result. In the timeframe you have set, Sasuke is too young to fight, Itachi does not have the Mangekyo, and Shisui is alive. Also, Hiashi and Hizashi are alive, but Neji, Hanabi and Hinata are too young to battle.

Both clans are known for having exceptionally strong shinobi and have dojutsu. Let's compare their dojutsu.

Byakugan - Allows user to see nearly every angle and through objects. Allows the user to see chakra and chakra points, thus allowing them to destroy them, cutting off their foes chakra. Sees through any genjutsu. Clan members are able to use this from birth (persumably).

Sharingan - Must be awakened, allows user to foresee foe's movements before they are placed into action, sees through any genjutsu, enables user to see chakra and chakra flow, enables user to be able to copy whatever is in their own ability. The amount of power the Sharingan has is determined by the tomoe.

Both are very useful and effective. Hyuga clan members would be able to block chakra points (when given the chance) and quickly defeat others. However, the Uchiha would be able to read their movements and form a distance between the fighters and use a fire technique to reduce them to ash. Of course, this will not always be the case. If I may also point out though, branch members do not know half of their clans jutsu. Of course the amount of effectiveness is determined by the strength of the user, but I think both clans would be well matched in that sense. Uchiha members must first awaken their Sharingan, but I think it was rather rare for a clansmate to never awaken their dojutsu.

In the timeline, Shisui would be the only one with the MS. Susanoo is awakened by the user obtaining the Mangekyo Sharingan in both eyes, so it is persumable that Shisui is able to perform this. Of course, this is hard to maintain. I doubt it would be out for long and it would be probably one of the last techniques Shisui would choose to use. In this timeline, none of the branch members know any main-family techniques. Main-family techniques are the strongest techniques and are only taught to main family members.

Amungst the Uchiha and Hyuga Clan members, many are probably jonin (or else there would be a lack of Police). It is stated that most Jonin know at least one or more Nature Transformations. However, I think that the Hyuga clan would spend less time on this, and the Uchiha would have more members overall with decent Nature Release capability. The reason I believe this is because the Hyuga clan specializes in Taijutsu, while the Uchiha specialize with Fire Techniques. In doing Taijutsu vs. Fire techniques, I believe the latter would win.

As stated many times before, the Uchiha could read the Hyuga's movements before they are able to perform them and shoot fire balls at them before they can block their chakra points.

Kudos to you if you actually read through that. **Rant over**