Board Thread:Versus Debates/@comment-26636534-20180205153025/@comment-26636534-20180216172342

@JamesDuh

JamesDuh wrote: The effect here was Kakashi's clone was in the Genjutsu for a small amount of time. That may be true, but Itachi wasn't able to capitalize on that effect. So it wasn't that effective.

JamesDuh wrote: And if the contradiction is apparent to you, why go with that theory? I still don't understand why this Manga Chapter even matters. No, your interpretation has the contradiction in it, not mine. That's why I don't understand it. The clone managed to overcome Itachi's genjutsu, quite easily. Itachi wasn't able to counter it. So, it speaks to the effectiveness of Itachi's genjutsu in general. That's the point.

JamesDuh wrote: I don't see you defending Itachi anywhere dude. So you definitely want Menma to win. Once again you are being selective. Most of my posts with Lone have been trying to show why the fight won't end with genjutsu. That's what I've been showing the whole time. Never have I stated that Menma would win. Defending Itachi? Against what? I've been trying to move on from the genjutsu point. Please try to understand where I'm coming from.

JamesDuh wrote: And no I'm not giving a scenario, I'm looking at points and basing the winner off the most facts. I also have not seen you answer Lone's question as I skimmed through the posts. Can you quote yourself, where you answered it? It will help me see your side of things. That's quite unfortunate. I was looking forward to your scenario. In any case, if you are not going to give one, I don't see the point of continuing. I don't know how objective you can be to be honest.

I've got no beef with you or anyone here. Just can't understand why certain things are taken the way users want them, instead of how they are. I might have not been clear on my points, but I've tried to clarify them. I think that if we all try to understand what the post is trying to mean, then we can have an actual discussion.