Board Thread:Theories and Speculation/@comment-25139119-20150820032806/@comment-26773508-20150923152602

GreatestSin wrote: Man of Sin wrote: So you're saying Hagoromo lied about having the Husk inside of him? wasnt the husk always in the moon? Isn't that the main confusion about the whole Juubi thing? If the Juubi was sealed with the Six Paths Chibaku Tensei, then how exactly did Hagoromo become the Jinchuriki? Did he fly to the moon and extract the chakra of the Juubi? Or did he extract the Juubi chakra while it was being imprisoned by the Six Paths Chibaku Tensei, leaving the husk to be trapped in the moon? If so, then the Gedo Mazo/Juubi Husk was in the moon the entire time? If true, then how did Hagoromo survive Juubi's chakra extraction without the husk? Or was Hagoromo special and could survive the chakra extraction without the husk?

If, on the other hand, Hagoromo sealed the entire Juubi (with the husk as well) inside his body, then what was the point of the Six Paths Chibaku Tensei? Or did he go to the moon, first sealed the chakra inside him, then summoned the husk from the moon's core and then sealed it within him too? Or did he just summon the Juubi back again and sealed the entire living monster within him, like Obito and Madara did?

Also, why was Hagoromo unable to recognise his mother's presence once the Juubi was sealed inside him, considering the fact that the Juubi is the merger of both Kaguya and the Shinju? Someone of Hagoromo's caliber should have sensed Kaguya's chakra once the Juubi was sealed inside him.

Another question: why did Kaguya turn into the Juubi in the first place? Couldn't she have simply absorbed the Shinjuu and then battled her sons like she battled Nartard and Sasgay? The Juubi displayed little to no intelligence during the War. So why did Kaguya transformed herself into a stupid, unintelligent monster? She was already dumb to begin with. I suppose that answers the question. She was dumb enough to go even dumber. But that sounds really lame.

Bambusek wrote: According to what was said near the end of manga and at the beginning of The Last, yes: Hagoromo only sealed Jyuubi's chakra inside him, the body was sealed on The Moon.

Considering we are nearing the first anniversary of Naruto's ending and people are still discussing things like that I would say, with all its flaws, Kishimoto made a great work. It was a great work up to the Kage Summit Arc. Things were really heating up that time. Then Kishi ruined the whole manga with the War. I'm not in a position to complain, but a bad ending leaves a really sour taste in the mouth. The War was way too rushed.