Board Thread:Consensus Track/@comment-4912646-20150519062854/@comment-17623-20150519111014

Its contradictory because the manga/databook/whatever presents it as contradictory. There is not much we can do about it.

We cannot ignore Tobi's version of events because his version of events just leaves out Hamura, but everything else checks out.

We cannot leave out Kurama's version of events because the fox was actually there.

Hagaromo simply adds Hamura to the mix but keeps everything as they were, with the Ten-Tails defiantly being sealed inside him.

Which then breaks realities because somehow the Ten-Tails had to be sealed in the moon but at the same time sealed inside Hagoromo. It could have been possible that like Kurama, the Ten-Tails was split into 2 halves, and one was sealed inside the Sage the other the moon. But that would require 2 Demonic Statues because based on Kurama's story Hagoromo did survive the the creation of the tailed beasts because he still had the statue in him.

Unless for some reason when Hagoromo and Hamura used Chibaku Tensei on the Ten-Tails and that didn't create the moon at that moment then no amount of back and forth will make this story make a lick of sense.