Board Thread:Wiki Discussions/@comment-1512913-20140521221412/@comment-28861328-20140522002313

No.

Its not secret code. Because "Sharingan" was what it was called. Three separate instances, spread over three separate chapters, was Sasuke's eye called the Rinnegan. Kaguya's, however, was called Sharingan and you want to force on us your interpretation, which is false, that it is a Rinnegan. "Just ignore the part where it says Sharingan! Its obviously a Rinnegan!" That's all I see when you argue this.

Your logic makes no sense. To me. To Omni, or really, anyone else you discuss it with.

So I'll say it again; wait for the Tankoban. If Kishi changes it there, so be it. If not, you have no basis for any argument against it. None. Your "interpretation" shouldn't come into this. Look at the translation. What does it say? Sharingan. Not Rinnegan. Not implied Rinnegan. Not "she used Sharingan powers through her Rinnegan". Sharingan.

Why you refuse to accept what is so plainly written before your eyes absolutely astounds me, but don't expect me to just bow out and accept logic that is that poorly thought through and start changing articles. It'll never happen.

Ever.