Board Thread:Episode Discussions/@comment-1251315-20141211121709/@comment-1512913-20141214101409

The whole "Rinnegan eyes crumbled because Madara died without them" explanation makes no sense considering that Madara died with a single transplanted Sharingan eye. So if the hypothesis were true, then Madara would have been Rinne-Tensei'd with a single Sharingan. So likely transplants do not carry over with Rinne-Tensei because they aren't part of the revived person's DNA/soul imprint or whatever shit.