Board Thread:Wiki Discussions and Support/@comment-142748-20141231093731/@comment-1207741-20150101234357

SuperSaiyaMan wrote: Its not possible since its not mentioned in any other account other than Obito's. None of the characters mentioned the Uchiha living anywhere else For maybe the eighth time since you've been editing the wiki, I'll tell you again: absence of evidence is not evidence of absence.

SuperSaiyaMan wrote: Itachi and Shisui's account, a first hand flashback would have mentioned discrimination and/or segregation while leading up to the massacre but...didn't. Itachi would've been, what, five at the time? What's there for him to remember?

SuperSaiyaMan wrote: Kishimoto had a trouble with show, don't tell when it came to the Uchiha's discrimination and seemed to take pains to show it didn't happen. He had plenty of opportunities backing Obito's account up but didn't take it. Why does he need to give additional proof of something if it's true?

SuperSaiyaMan wrote: I mention 'new construction' since Obito's account explicitly says that they were forcibly relocated. That the 'new' Uchiha District would be newly constructed. He doesn't say a completely new living area would be built. People can move into old buildings, after all. Or, like, Building Relocation no Jutsu.

SuperSaiyaMan wrote: The segregation and discrimination was merely a lie Obito fabricated to get Sasuke to turn on Konoha and join him. And yet he admits to having petty reasons for helping Itachi to kill the clan. If his sole concern is winning Sasuke's loyalty and he'll say anything to accomplish that, he's not doing a good job.

SuperSaiyaMan wrote: Lets look at another recent anime and manga where a people were segregated and discriminated against: Full Metal Alchemist with the Ishvalan People. We see their condition's before their uprising. We see how the Armestrians treated them. And we see the horror of their extermination.

We didn't get ANY of that for the Uchiha. So why should we believe Obito's account, NeedleJizo? More important question: why should we care what Arakawa does with her series?

SuperSaiyaMan wrote: All we have is a single claim of Obito, who is a known liar. That's a fine reason for forum discussions, but it isn't the wiki's responsibility to invalidate a claim because a character is in the habit if lying. We report what happens, we do not cherry-pick truths.

One final time: you need direct evidence that it's a lie, as in a character going out of their way to say, "I'm so glad we Uchiha can live wherever we want to!" or, "Geez, it sure would be easier to spy on the Uchiha if we forced them to all live in the same place. Too bad that's not going to happen because we were explicitly told it won't."