Board Thread:Versus Debates/@comment-43599250-20200124022237/@comment-9782468-20200204201301

Whoa whoa whoa lol.

Kisame has more chakra, but specifically excels at fighting chakra heavy users. Madara is not specialized in this way, and just is massively skilled in most areas with lots of reserves to boot.

Madara not being faster than Itachi is speculation, whether you're for or against it. It's not some ironclad fact.

Madara not outdoing Itachi in Taijutsu is also speculation, whether you're for or against it.

If we include Madara's Perfect Susanoo, that does not mean we automatically consider Itachi's novel feats because the anime and novels are on different levels of canon.

I agree on the last bit though. It mainly depends on how long it'll last. But that's one of the reasons this whole "healthy Itachi" thing annoys me. We have no idea what his reserves would be like, nor his acual chakra levels, and the closest we have as a baseline is Itachi as an Edo.