Board Thread:Naruto Discussions/@comment-24120130-20140607191120/@comment-28861328-20140701172114

Mrlmm0605 wrote: It is totally impossible for Hagoromo to have a kekkei genkai not possessed by Kaguya. The laws of heredity, which Kishi tries really hard to abide by, deny even the possibility. Therefore, Kaguya had to have a Rinnegan. It can, though, be a subtly genetically different Rinnegan than that of Hagoromo, because of the recombination of genes. In a story context, all chakra abilities had to have originated from Kaguya, because al chakra originated from Kaguya. There is no middle ground. Either Kaguya has the Rinnegan, or there is no such thing as a Rinnegan. One of those is obviously false, so we have but one option.

Really?

I'm curious. Which laws of heredity has Kishi "tried hard" to follow? In fact, which laws of genetics period, has he followed? I mean, I don't know about you, but if I inject my mother's blood into me, its not going to suddenly make my eyes go from blue to brown (Madara suddenly gaining Hashirama's genetic traits from the same thing), and, in fact, injecting someone's genetic material into your body is pretty dangerous.

Perhaps you mean the laws concerning the passing down of kekkei genkai? But the laws you speak of would say that the Sharingan would've deprecated even further by now, just by the fact that mutations do occur more often the further from the source (which you claim as the Rinnegan [Kabuto says otherwise btw]) you go. And the nasty bit about what inbreeding (which preservation of these kekkei genkai would require) would do to a clan after centuries and centuries of it.

And while we're on that, why don't you tell me the probability that Kaguya's three dojutsu (that's right, three) would perfectly divide between the bloodlines of her two sons, so that one would have the Byakugan and the second would have the Sharingan/Rinnegan? Hm? The chances are much, much, much higher that (depending on which is a dominant trait, or whether they both are) the brothers would actually both have the same eyes. But he's speaking the truth, right, Elveonora?

Elveonora wrote: Please, don't speak the truth, some individuals around here are allergic to it. And neither of us want to be responsible for a potential shock that might occur.

Well, it would have to be the truth first, and he couldn't be further from it. Same with you. I'd prefer you keep the snarky remarks to yourself though. Its getting old fast.