Board Thread:Versus Debates/@comment-9782468-20150305031956/@comment-26302001-20150305164450

Itachi would win. Sword of Totsuka and Yata Mirror, full health and full eyesight? Itachi wins in the end because he is a better thinker and is smarter. It takes brains and battle sense to win in Naruto and Itachi has both, shown by how quickly he figured out how to beat Chibaku Tensei. Madara has more chakra and most likely some more Ninjutsu, but that's it. They are tied in everything else except Genjutsu and speed, Itachi wins there. Proof? Sasuke was able to stab sage mode influenced Madara through the arm hinting he was just a tad faster. But it was shown before Itachi is faster than Sasuke in their fight. As a weaker version of himself(Edo Tensei) he was the same speed as Sasuke(Able to match Kurama Chakra Cloak Naruto in speed in the Jinchuriki vs Nagato and Itachi fight). Itachi has Genjutsu and Speed, Madara has Ninjutsu and Stamina/Chakra to his advantage, Itachi has Sword of Totsuka and Yata Mirror. If this was a battle to the death, where they each knew the other HAD to die.. Itachi would win in the very end albeit possibly barely alive.