Board Thread:Naruto Discussions/@comment-24953394-20140611085622/@comment-18497248-20140612123125

Super Kurama wrote: Marc Zaddy wrote: Super Kurama wrote: Elveonora wrote: She might have merged with the Shinju later on possibly, but originally they were definitely separate and you should know that if you read the manga. For Hagoromo's brother being the Shinju... seriously? So he fought himself? I"m not taking it in as a fact or anything. I know Hagoromo told the story himself - and therefore, he has no real reason to lie. I'm questioning not only the true identity of Kaguya, but the Shinju itself. As far as I'm concerned, everything is still up in the air. I read everything and I feel as if something isn't right or there's a big ass hole in the middle of the plot.

Well nothing about the Shinju is up in the air, only Kaguya's backstory is, and seeing as how we know the Shinju's backstory I don't see why you would lump them together.

As far as I'm concerned - is what I said. I'll only be satsified when the manga is over and, well, I wouldn't really call it a back story, but something about the Shinju isn't entirely out there. I lump them together because I simply want to rule out any possibilities, so lets quit lingering on that.

I'm not lingering on anything, don't put them in the same box, they're not. Writing it like that makes me question why and how you figure they are.

As for the backstory, what exactly is missing for you?? What more do you need/want to know about the Shinju?? Keep in mind, if we learn Kaguya's backstory the Shinju will not be the focus, as that little bit was already explained.