Board Thread:Consensus Track/@comment-4521917-20161120182008/@comment-4271790-20161126080441

M4ND0N wrote: In no way am I advocating for the complete removal of the Boruto sections. I'm simply suggesting we relocate them to the movie section of each character article involved in the film. And yet, that was exactly what you did in this edit of yours. "Relocating" the movie section is something you did not do in your unilaterally-decisive edit. You name two of your threads "Getting rid of the Boruto movie sections" and "Replace Boruto Movie sections with Boruto manga sections". What part of those titles and the content of the beginning posts of all three of your threads imply or suggest "relocating"? And yet you claim you're not advocating the complete removal or replacement of anything. So which is it, hmm? And moving the Boruto movie sections under the general movie sections in character articles could work, though I don't see the point. We are going to have sections named "Boruto: Naruto the Movie" and "Boruto: Naruto Next Generations" in the "Epilogue" sections of character articles. That distinguishes the information just fine. We cover both, differences in the trivia sections, blah blah blah. M4ND0N wrote: The issue I'm seeing here is that irregardless of which version is canon and which isn't, the manga version does contain noticeable differences - and scenes from the core story that didn't exist in the movie. Example: Gaara has more scenes in the manga than the movie. What do we do with him? There's no place for the storylines in the Boruto Movie arc of the manga that weren't in the movie because the only Naruto Next Generation tabs are placed after the movie tab. The reason why I say that the differences aren't too significant is because, as Ravenlot 27 meticulously pointed out, the most we've seen is that some characters look or are dressed up differently, and there are more scenes that the movie didn't have. Cool. This isn't Dragon Ball Super and DBZ: Battle of Gods & DBZ: Resurrection 'F'  where things were flat out retconned and both versions of events had explicitly different material going on.

Regarding Gaara, it's quite simple. He has more/different scenes in the manga than the movie. Cool. One can simply create a "Boruto: Naruto Next Generations" section in the "Epilogue" section of his article under the "Boruto: Naruto the Movie" section detailing what happened in the manga.

Also, one very important, crucial and critical detail that I think needs to be pointed out: Do remember that in the manga, Boruto the character is reminiscing over the events of the Boruto movie while battling his enemy. Everything regarding the retelling of the Boruto movie in the manga is all in Boruto's head. What we're reading are not current events, as opposed to the movie. You could literally begin every beginning sentence under the "Boruto: Naruto Next Generations" sections in the appropriate character articles with "in Boruto's remembering of events, so and so happened..." and that would be completely accurate and factual (which, is once again why I don't see the point in relocating anything). M4ND0N wrote: That's the issue I'm seeing. We should just do it like the Dragon Ball Wiki, albeit in a less messy manner. Not saying we should remove information What the One Piece Wiki does and what the Dragon Ball Wiki does works for them. Good. Awesome. That doesn't always mean we have to apply the same thing here. May we take ideas from other wikis from time to time? Sure. But in this case, your idea of doing so has been rejected, ignored, and rejected/ignored again by the community.

And a final thing: while I admit your persistence is admirable, in all three of your threads, you were pretty set on removing the Boruto movie information only for you to change your mind/clarify midway through this thread that you intend on "relocating" information after getting opposed again. Ending this thread because no one reading the original post and/or the posts before your clarification is going to think that you plan on "relocating" anything and that's going to confuse everybody with them assuming you want to remove stuff again and them subsequently opposing you yet again. So I suggest you bring up your "relocating" idea on Talk:Narutopedia, Talk:Boruto: Naruto Next Generations, other appropriate talkpages (or dare I say a fourth thread, which I wouldn't recommend at this point, but whatever), etc etc so we can start from a clean slate. Closing now.