Board Thread:Wiki Discussions/@comment-1512913-20140521221412/@comment-28861328-20140523183222

TheUltimate3 wrote: Oh my shit this is still going.

Unfortunately, yes it is. Apparently the decision to wait on the talk page wasn't enough for some around here, so misconstruing the translation given by Seel and Omni is the go-to defense for this theory now. *sighs*

@Elve: You've still yet to respond to this

I'm not saying its impossible that Kaguya doesn't have the Rinnegan. What I'm telling you is that Kishimoto named Kaguya's one and Sasuke's the other. It is his series. If he wants Kaguya's to be Sharingan and Sasuke's to be Rinnegan, as crazy as it sounds, that is his right as the author. It is not our right, as the readers, to correct what we see as something completely nonsensical.

You just can't do that.

Its one thing to draw logical conclusions in the lack of a definitive statement, but this instance doesn't require that because both instances have very blatantly had a name applied to each one. Sharingan and Rinnegan. It is still possible that Kishimoto could correct the meaning in the tankoban, and if he does, I will happily change Kaguya's dojutsu, but if he doesn't change it? It remains Sharingan.

That's our lot as readers.

You know I'm one of the strong proponents of the "logical conclusion" group, as opposed to the people who literally want to be spoon fed by Kishi, but, just like with Rinbo: Hengoku instance (where people were jumping on the Deva Path boat from day one), there are certain issues where you have to be cautious because we haven't been given the complete picture yet. This is one of them.