Board Thread:Naruto Discussions/@comment-25645405-20141128183407/@comment-4366149-20141202053308

Seelentau wrote: They are chakra natures, but they aren't elemental natures. They're not part of the elemental chart Yamato explained to Naruto and they work entirely different, because they're created during the process of creating chakra, not afterwards.

Yes, I know all that, and I agree. Yin chakra is normal chakra made of only spiritual energy. Combining it with elemental chakra would not create a new nature, because to create a new nature, one needs elemental chakra, as explained by Kakashi. I really don't see your problem here, sorry.

This is not true, as in Kakashi did not say that. (The best that you can argue is that he somewhat implied it). Kakashi simply stated that the combination of any two of the five basic natures belongs to the domain of kekkei genkai. Simple and short. None of the three different translations that I've seen (including Viz) says anything significantly different. I've repeated this several times already and I've continuously asked you for evidence that Kakashi ever said the things you're claiming.

Seel, go back and read the chapters, and HONESTLY ask yourself the same question that I've been asking you.