Board Thread:Theories and Speculation/@comment-1512913-20161119171442/@comment-734582-20161207171618

Kakashisologod wrote: According to haku and yamato u need 1 type of chakra in each hand to perform kekei genkai.That means onoki performs lava realese in 1 hand(meaning he must unite 2 chakra natures) and in the other wind realease,when he claps hands together puff dust realease.Thats at least what i think. The problem is that this argument is self-defeating: We know that a KKG requires an element in each hand. Why then can Onoki use two in one hand, when it goes against what we know of Kekkei Genkai?

It seems more logical and less contradictory if Ohnoki does a simultaneous triple nature transformation with the figure of chakra he forms. The nature transformation doesn't take place until the chakra's in the 3D figure (E.g cube/cone/cylinder).

Elveonora wrote: But I don't really think it's possible to mix combined natures with basic natures, since a combined nature is just more than one basic nature used simultaneously. Again, as per Yamato explanation, there really isn't such a thing as Wood Release nature. I think that is my second problem with the "mixed KKG" model. A Collaboration jutsu combines two elements into it's logical combination. IE wind + fire = hotter fire. Water+Earth=mud. etc. A Kekkei Genkai doesn't mix elements, it mixes the nature of elements. Boil Release has a number of forms which combine certain aspects (Steam = water + heat, caustics = water + chemical energy), whereas the two elements together would douse flames and not much more.

In the same sense, Dust Release combines Earth (Power over solids) with Air (diffuse nature) and Fire (chemical energy) to create a technique that breaks down atomic bonds, which is beyond a mere combination of elements.