Board Thread:Wiki Discussions/@comment-1512913-20140521221412/@comment-3568954-20140525084202

Cabecote wrote: First time poster, so bare with me. Kinda off-topic, but man you guys sure like having heated conversations eheheh Peace and love bros. I understand Elveonora's point, it's all about semantics. "Having the power" is different than "Having per say". For example, we saw ET Madara using Susanoo while Rinnegan was activated, so he still "had the power of the Sharingan", eventough he wasn't using them. It might be the same with Kaguya or may be in fact a Sharingan. All this situation and 10-Tails eye it's such an odd ball that I get headaches thinking about it. By the way, I don't remember who pointed it out on the conversation, but I also wonder why people affected by Infinite Tsukyomi have Rinnegan reflected in theirs eyes.

Edo Tensei Madara had susanoo with Rinnegan because his Rinnegan is both a sharingan and a Rinnegan in order for him to have the Rinnegan activated he has to have his EMS activated first. its just that there are no tomoe on his Rinnegan

and the power of the sharingan is bound to the eye itself so having the power of the Sharingan is just that. having the sharingan also the panels clearly show the third eye closed and then he starts talking about Infinite Tsukoyomi while he is talking about IT her third eye is open indicating that her Third eye is the eye that casts IT(infinte Tsukoyomi) and since we know IT is a sharingan genjutsu then the third eye MUST be a sharingan

and the shinobi casted into IT do not have a reflection of the Rinnegan they have the Reflection of a spiraled sharingan similar to the eye that Indra was original shown to have