Board Thread:Naruto Discussions/@comment-24120130-20140607191120/@comment-3568954-20140620120304

Elveonora wrote: Shinju, Kaguya and Madara's eye is just the original Rinnegan, not any merger or Sharinnegan BS.

that is the problem people like you keep saying that it is just the original Rinnegan when they have not once said that in the manga in fact the manga says the opposite. Hagoromo said beside the byakugan my mother had the sharingan he did not say she had the Rinnegan people like you are assuming because sasuke said a genjutsu cast with a Rinnegan can be broken by another Rinnegan means that her eye is a Rinnegan which is just an assumption. Madara had the Rinnnegan so therefore any visually based genjutsu is by extension a Rinnegan cast genjutsu