Board Thread:Naruto Discussions/@comment-1512913-20180923130046/@comment-4974066-20180924165824

Yea, I don't think this follows.

1. The reason there was such a big tizzy about Magnet Release is because of the fact that it's a KKG, which means by nature, it MUST contains 2 basic elements. And so the discussion about it revolved around trying to figure out what the 2 elements were. Because it necessarily demanded an explanation. And Rasa's D4 profile provided the best explanation of what Magnet Release NEEDED to contain (so far). The nature of Medical Jutsu does not, however, necessarily demand an explanation. There's nothing implicit about the definition of Medical Jutsu that suggests that it MUST contain some basic element like Magnet Release. So trying to appeal to how Magnet Release was treated to justify the same treatment of Tsunade's Medical Jutsu just doesn't work imo.

2. Why would only Tsunade's Medical Jutsu be Yang Release? Because she has Yang in the D4? Well, of course she does. She's a Senju. And we know from the D4 and the manga that the Senju predominately inherited Yang from the So6P. All Senju characters who have their Chakra Natures shown in the D4 have Yang Release. If anything, it's likely that she facilitates the use of Yang Release in her Medical Jutsu. She's also an Uzumaki descendant, which means she has natural healing abilities so that also helps.

3. Why would only Mystical Palm be classified as Yang Release? Why would only one jutsu within a subcategory be classified a specific nature while other jutsu of the same subcategory not be? If the answer is Tsunade, I'll again refer to number 2.

Personally, I DO think that Medical Jutsu is either Yang or both Yin and Yang, but if it is, I don't think it's because of any of the reasons stated. I think somewhere in the manga it said that Medical Jutsu is either Yin or Yang Release, but so was Genjutsu and it took someone to actually state that "Yin Release means Genjutsu" in the manga for the wiki finally do something about it. While I personally think that this means Medical Jutsu is Yang, I don't think anything should be done until someone specifically says so.