Board Thread:Versus Debates/@comment-33229263-20171019104931/@comment-734582-20171021112605

LegionZero wrote: Unless its mistranslated, Kabuto said that his hypothesis was correct. Depends on the hypothesis he refers to. After all, he hypothesized that Madara didn't die in the Valley of the End, and somehow obtained the combined power of the Senju and Uchiha. At this point he already knew Obito was using a false name. LegionZero wrote: Both people to unlock the Rinnegan after Hagoromo both had Uchiha eyes and 2 people to recieve his power later who did not have Uchiha eyes didnt get a Rinnegan. Not sure who the second person is to receive Hagoromo's power. But again, it's sample bias. Just because two Sharingan users get the eye doesn't mean it's necessary. Especially since Zetsu hints at no special requirement. The fact that you need to recreate Hagoromo's chakra to me suggests that the Sharingan isn't needed, all that's needed is some flesh from both transmigrants.

LegionZero wrote: Unless you are saying any shmuck that gets Hagoromos chakra gets a Rinnegan and 6PSM. But the hole in this theory comes when Madara did not get 6PSM and Ashura had no Rinnegan. But we already know that Hagoromo didn't like the idea of one person holding all the power. Why would he give Ashura the Rinnegan when that goes against everything he believed in? Especially since Sasuke/Naruto shows that he liked the Uchiha/Senju power divide?

As far as i'm aware Hagoromo didn't have SPSM before the Juubi. Obito and Madara both got it from the Juubi.