Board Thread:Theories and Speculation/@comment-26889573-20151008053113/@comment-1872728-20151018150838

LegionZero wrote: @Georgio: Shinju can't be the root of the Rinne Sharingan but it can grant the ability to produce chakra without actually having chakra itself..... Don't you see the inconsistency here? Kaguya got all of her abilities because of the Shinju. There is nothing to suggest otherwise. It's like having a Tailed Beast, obtaining them or their chakra grants their abilities. By your logic no technique in the series actually happened because the Shinju lacked the ability to perform them. Or that Kakashi had Susanoo/Kamui in him all along, he just needed Oboto's eye first. Or that Sage Mode was always within Naruto and he just needed the Natural Energy. That's not what I meant, at all. You're not understanding what I'm trying to say. I'm saying that Shinju can't be the only root of the Rinne Sharingan, and not that it can't be the root of the Rinne Sharingan. Hence why I said that the Rinne Sharingan is manifested with the combination of both Shinju and Kaguya. I never stated anything about Shinju not being the originator, I just said that the Shinju is one of the originator. Changing other people's words doesn't make your theory any better.