Board Thread:Versus Debates/@comment-24230661-20150420034729/@comment-24142271-20150421115431

Ishidate is really only adept at Taijutsu as far as we have seen and that Stone glove thing. His taijutsu skills as far as i remember were only on par with part one Kakashi and multiple Naruto shadow clones. He utilized a poison gas that hindered and weakened the enemies movements though i think someone as powerful as doto (along with his armour) could negate these effects.

Doto has many abilities, powerful ice release jutsu, prototype chakra armour with which he could use to fully negate genjutu and sasuke's chidori, he could glide around using his armours built-in wings so he could avoid Isidate even with the poison gas Ishidate would have to reach him though he could use his rock projectiles which could still be dodged, and he was also very powerful being able to break large pieces of ice with on hit. So...in my opinion, Doto hands down.

P.S. The guy can negate a chidori, who's to say that his armour could not negate other such abilities like the gloves and the poison gas.