Board Thread:Versus Debates/@comment-34656247-20180517100121/@comment-33286580-20180519063254

hard to decide on the victor.

for staters lets get something unnecessary out of the picture - and that is Itachi. yes. i am saying so. there is nothing Itachi can bring to the table other that the Totsuka Sword which can be useful. in that regards Minato already has Shiki Fuin so no real need for the sword. the problem is that whether an already dead person can use the Shiki Fuin?

Another thing to note - Minato cannot use Biju Sage Mode. only Naruto did that. just because he can go SM doesn't mean he automatically can do BSM

Power wise, with Kurama's aid Minato matches up with Edo Madara. Minato has advantage in speed and Madara in versatality of jutsu. wood release may trouble Minato's Biju Mode but all Minato has to do is leave Biju Mode and get into KCM, like Naruto did and avoid wood release. so far Madara hasnt shown the same ability of supression that Hashirama showed so he only has wood dragon to supress Biju mode. the forest jutsu can be blasted of with bijudama or Minato can FTG out of it, same strategy for flower jutsu.

this will go down to who seals away their opponent first, as damaging other isnt going to weaken them or kill them in any way.

the thing is like Minato has superior sealing technique, Madara also has Rinnegan which has Naraka Path which can very much seal away the soul of Minato too.

Madara can simply drop Meteor on Minato and use Naraka to catch the still regenrating Minato and seal his soul away. Minato can also use FTG to get around and seal away Madara, not necessarily with Shiki Fuin as he is bet to come up with powerful sealing technique being Fuinjutsu expert to seal away Madara's body like the alliance sealed away most Edo.

probably the extra, but unneded help of Itachi may come trough.

overall, i'll give Minato the win say 7 out of 10 times.

the thing is can Madara use Limbo as an Edo - he didnt show it, but he had the Rinnegan and was at his prime after all.