Board Thread:Versus Debates/@comment-35155071-20180330190048/@comment-35250150-20180408105143

I think you tipped this fight in Obito's favour by giving him the rinnegan. So Obito has his Kamui intangibility, Hashirama DNA and the Rinnegan and Itachi just has his MS? Yet you take away Itachi's MS trump card Susanno, but Obito still has Kamui which comes from his MS? How is that fair?

We gotta go by what's stated in the canon itself. Obito himself stated that if Itachi knew all of his secrets he'd be dead when Itachi's Amaterasu activated out of Sasuke's sharingan. The same way Pain said if Jiraya had figured out his secret he would've lost.

Like it or not, for all his immense capacity, Obito loses to Itachi. Itachi is a one of a kind ninja. An elite among the elite. There's not a single person barring god level people like Haguromo that can beat him easily.

Obito is crazy strong, especially with all the attachments, but in a fight with Itachi, he'd have to absorb Itachi as quickly as possible because the moment Itachi figures out how his Kamui works, he's dead. And if Kakashi can figure it out, Itachi can figure it out.

Rinnegan changes things. Giving Obito rinnegan and his Kamui sharingan is overkill. Very few people can stand up to that. So keep it fair and limit it to their base sharingan abilities. Itachi wins. With Rinnegan, I think Obito edges him out. Itachi's smart enough to figure out a way to beat that, but it won't be easy by any means.