Board Thread:Naruto Discussions/@comment-25645405-20141128183407/@comment-4366149-20141202210444

Seelentau wrote: It has nothing to do with any claims I'm making. Yin and Yang are no elemental chakra natures, even if they were combined with elemental chakra, there would be no new elemental nature. Kakashi explained it and Yin and Yang simply do not fit into that explanation. That's logic in its purest form. This, again, is the part you're making up from nowhere. The only thing that lends credit to it is Kakashi's silence.

Oh and yes, in fictional works, silence is evidence of absence. Simply because there's nothing going on behind the scenes, the manga is only what we're presented. The characters don't talk when we aren't looking or anything.

This whole statement is really really bad logic, especially the bolded O~O, and it's way too easy to tear apart... but meeh. Anyways, you finally admitted that the only "evidence" for you claim (i.e. the impossibility of combining Yin or Yang with the basic natures) is Kakashi's silence on the matter. Well, it's not like you even needed to admit it since it was conspicuously evident.