Talk:Adamantine Nyoi

This page should not be deleted, but should in fact be changed to one focusing on creatures and summons of Naruto. The information here needs some citation in aspects, but is largely misplaced with an obscure page. Consider a new page or merging before deletion. Lurking Gnomes 16:24, 15 March 2008 (UTC)


 * The page however looks like a very old version of List of Naruto summons from Wikipedia. Thats pretty much the reason why its a candidate for deletion.--TheUltimate3 19:13, 15 March 2008 (UTC)


 * Then shall we open it up to discussion on what to do with it? Information is information to me, the form in which it is matters little to me, but rather then deleting it immediately, perhaps we can figure out what to do with it instead of striking the material entirely? Lurking Gnomes 16:43, 16 March 2008 (UTC)


 * No... Quite simply, the page has a deletion tag there because it is a copyright violation. The entire point of the tag there, if you'll even read the reason that it gives "This article was copied from the page text of the wrong article on Wikipedia. This page needs to be deleted, and the Wikipedia page needs to be copied to the correct title on this wiki. The parts of that page which are relevant to this page should then be moved to here."
 * So breaking it down...
 * It's a copyright violation so we can't keep it.
 * It is missing all the source formatting.
 * The article still still exists on Wikipedia.
 * And so we should delete this and copy the original content with the fully formatted source in a way that isn't a copyvio.
 * The article also contains a lot of cruft that doesn't belong in the article. The Wikipedia page still exists so only the relevant portions should be copied. The other stuff is useless to this article so copying from that Wikipedia page into other articles is out of this scope.
 * So no, there is no discussion on what to do with it, because this page is just a duplicate of something there is already a better version of to copy from, the material still exists, and in an even better format. Not to mention that the stuff here is illegal and could cause legal issues for the wiki if used. ~ NOTASTAFF Daniel Friesen (DanTMan, Nadir Seen Fire) (talk) current discussion Mar 16, 2008 @ 17:39 (UTC)