Board Thread:Naruto Discussions/@comment-3232093-20140617193601/@comment-4271790-20140818202756

Ten Tailed Fox wrote: And here's where that hits a nitch. According to Madara [based on a tablet rewritten by Black Zetsu, Kaguya's will], the Sharingan-powered Rinnegan, which Madara awakened, only comes forth from those who already possesses the Rinnegan. Is it not, then, possible that Kaguya also began with Sharingan and progressed to her Rinnegan? After all, Sasuke's Rinnegan is virtually the same as Kaguya's (minus three tomoe) and awakened from his Sharingan when he gained Hagoromo's power. Read my comment again, I edited it a little bit, lol. So maybe the Sharingan and Rinnegan came at the same time due to Kaguya's third eye. And no, it isn't possible. Kaguya was a special case. Just like Hagoromo was. He was the only one to use a TSBs without being a jinchuuriki. Orochimaru and Kabuto had no knowledge of Kaguya's existence, nor her third eye, therefore their theory only applied to Rinnegan with Hagoromo's influence. She didn't begin with a Sharingan that evolved into a Rinnegan, she began with a Sharingan-powered Rinnegan. The Sharingan requires little chakra compared to the Rinnegan, in her case, she ate the chakra fruit which gave her unrivalled power, and she started with the puny Sharingan? No. She had the nine-tomoe Rinnegan from the get-go. The tablet never stated that awakening Hagoromo's dual Rinnegan brought forth Kaguya's third-eyed one. Awakening Hagoromo's Rinnegan would break the seal on the Demonic Statue of the Outer Path (which was the TT, and technically Kaguya herself). Plus Madara basically had Kaguya sealed within him, he just used her power to awaken the third-eyed Rinnegan on his forehead. Then BZ betrayed him and... you know how the story goes. And Sasuke's Rinnegan is not the same as Kaguya, it may have three less tomoe, but you have forgotton that it is light purple like Hagoromo's.