Board Thread:Wiki Discussions/@comment-25075055-20140506161733/@comment-1210805-20140507091355

I feel like this has gone the wrong way. We shouldn't be treating things as manga vs anime. It's not worth the trouble, rather, we should be trying to make such things work together as best we can. We need consistency. That consistency could come in many forms but I think we should establish some guidelines to help things along. Consistency will give readers a better experience overall. In my mind some possible guidelines are:

1)Tabs should be used in the following circumstances:

a)If a character has major differences between mediums (this is probably going to be the cause of most conflict as it's probably the most opinion driven part of all this). Alternatively, we could consider adding coloured manga tabs to every character page, though this could get clunky.

b)If a character has multiple "main" appearances in the series (Obito, the characters with Part I and II depictions).

2)If image tabs are used, images should be cropped appropriately for consistent sizing. There's no reason for A's manga image to show his whole upper body.

3)Images from both mediums should be the most accurate offered by their medium of origin. Things like lighting, colouring, proportions etc should be taken into account. So, for someone like Mei, where the difference between mediums is her lipstick colour, her manga image should actually show her lipstick. For someone like Kurama, we should have an image with neutral lighting that shows his actual colour.

Those are my thoughts.