Board Thread:Naruto Discussions/@comment-5054236-20150717003436/@comment-24808887-20151211191301

Keaire wrote: Why?

Cause we never had such occurrence in storyline, making up something that was never stated by author to give ones statement better face value as far fetched as it can be.

Keaire wrote: He spoke of Madara (Indra), Hashirama (Asura) and Kurama (10 Tails chakras) coming together (3 separate things), right after he appeared out from Madara's lower half.

So? His chakra (Indra + Ashura) got mixed with more powerful TT chakra and was able to manifest. If Hagoromo having two chakra types is reason for(as you now imply) him to manifest then he don't need Madara's lower body cause he already has them considering he gave it respectively to Naruto and Sasuke again as you say.

Keaire wrote: Tailed Beast chakra is different (for reasons not really made clear) from the chakra everyone else uses. Why would combining chakra from 9 Beast give you the same power as Asura + Indra coupled with nature?

This very simple actually cause Tailed Beast chakra or more specifically Ten-Tails chakra is chakra of Kaguya in her degenerated form so ofcourse TT jin - person who has weakened Kaguya inside him gets SPS cause Hagoromo in first place got from Her and that's why being TT jin - host of depowered Kaguya is "another" way to gain SPS

Keaire wrote: What's wrong with having two different types of chakra?

Nothing except every person or creature that has chakra in Narutoverse weald his own uniqe chakra and even when some "steals" and add to his own it will affect his original chakra, and no one ever had simultaneously tow different types of his own chakra. If you impling that Hagoromo got second from someone then again i must remind you that: Hago was SPS before TT jin and there was no "humans" with chakra beside him, his bro and their momma.

Keaire wrote: Why is Asura's chakra a separate thing from his body?

Since when body=chakra? To create chakra one must combine Yang energy from his body: cells, organs ect and Yin energy from his mind: traning, experience, will. Asura got from Hagoromo his body and thus his Yang energy he combined it with his own "normal" human Yin energy and got Asura's chakra, while Indra got Hagoromo's eyes and his mind and thus his Yin energy which he combined with his own "normal" human Yang energy and got his Indra's chakra. When Indra's eyes(Hagoromo's eye) come to contact with Hagoromo chakra(Asura's Yang and Indra's Yin without their "normal" halves) it become Rinnegan and when Asura's body(Hagoromo's body) come to contact with Hagoromo chakra(Asura's Yang and Indra's Yin without their "normal" halves) it gains SPS naturally.

Keaire wrote: Independently from and another way, but you still think it creates the same Yin/Yang power?

As i said above it is all because of Kaguya.

Keaire wrote: Eh? Not really. A notification was sent to my email, so I checked it out.......

Well at least my post you replied to is half year old.