Board Thread:Naruto Discussions/@comment-29752445-20160826022014/@comment-25122992-20160827150719

Hpm, I must admit that with Hamuura's cooperation added, the theory makes for me somewhat more sense. But it still contains some contradictions. Firstly, we don't even know which of the brothers died first - Hagoromo or Hamura. With Hagoromo being the host of Ten-Tails (at least, its chakra), I have an impression that his longevity should've increased exponentially, while Hamura has never got such a thing. Thus the possibility of Hamura dying before Hagoromo can't be excluded.

Secondly, it's a pretty lame reason for Hagoromo to ask Hamura to lend him the Statue. I imagined their dialogue for a moment: "Hey, bro, will you mind if I borrow the Gedo Statue from you for a while?" "Wait, wait, what are you planning to do?" "Well, I decided to create some cute beasties out of the Ten-Tails, but I need to give them a proper talk about their bonds and everything, which I cannot do without the Statue prolonging my life. I promise I'll give it back after this." "..."

And thirdly, the Beasts' extraction doesn't mean an instand death, especially for the man like Hagoromo. For example, after Kaguya was sealed by Naruto/Sasuke and Madara got free from her, even while the latter was going to die with no beasts inside, he still had some time to talk with Hashi about their ways of life and him choosing the wrong path. I doubt that Hagoromo couldn't have at least as much time for talk as Madara did, which seems pretty enough to gave the parting words to the Beasts.

Besides, regarding Madara, it's not a contradiction. I didn't mean that Hagoromo wasn't able to summon the Statue (even while Madara was). I just noted that Hagoromo could be unable to restore the seal afterwards, something Madara has never tried to do.