Board Thread:Versus Debates/@comment-29414628-20160802152411/@comment-25122992-20160803205805

Andy Roque wrote: Probably a tie, I don't believe Madara can kill an Edo, and Minato would probably use the reaper death seal, if not, Minato's use of a tailed beast and being unable to be defeated since he is an edo gives him the win There's no guarantee that reaper seal can't kill an Edo-shinobi. In fact, given its mechanics, it's more likely that it would kill even an Edo-user, since it seals the soul of the user as well, which means that Minato's soul would be still sealed away, ending the match in double-KO.

Also, Madara showed he can deal with reanimations pretty easily, immobilising them with the black receivers.