Board Thread:Theories and Speculation/@comment-45510280-20200416210937/@comment-6769189-20200429191850

Squinty97 wrote: @Jason isn't that just a list showing where these stories take place in a the timeline? That doesn't mean they actually happened in the story. Though I look forward to your responses to my other arguments. Thats kind of exactly what it means. If it wasnt part of the timeline it wouldnt be given a place in the timeline. Lokk at the the Dragonball movies.

Squinty97 wrote:

@Legion I've already given several reasons why the feat doesn't make sense to me, if you're going to just ignore them that's fine. Ive seen the reasons and at their core you dont like how it fits in with the manga.

You say it is inconsistant with his feats, but he never used Tsukuyomi for the kill in the anime or manga. IIRC Izumi was the only person he killed in the novel with Tsykuyomi in the entirety of the franchise. Where is the inconsistancy?

You say it is inconsistant with his personality, but i dont think you are taking the context into account. This was Itachi's girlfriend, who he loved as much as Sasuke. She was his first kill of the massacre, and was the kill he needed to harden his heart to go through with the rest of it. The Itachi we got to "know" was 12-16 years after the massacre. He was already hardened. Killing Izumi was the first step to becoming the Itachi we seen for most of the manga. He gave her mercy

Missy0124 wrote: @Squinty97

That's why there are pacific canon tiers putting one source above another eg boruto is more canon than the novels btw lying is not something that should done so causally and we don't determine what's canon that's why the wiki has a canon policy Did you just call a wiki mod a liar? He just explained that the wiki policy is for organization purposes. The canon policy itself states that the policy was created so that people didnt argue over it when editing articles. The wiki policy also says its based off the Star Wars policy, not anythimg official

You do realize that the wiki, and extension wiki policies, are made by fans/moderators of the wiki? No one official from Shueish/Shonen Jump/Kishimoto/Kodachi/V Jump or any other organization associated with production or publication of the series has come out and said canon is tiered