Board Thread:Wiki Discussions/@comment-1512913-20140521221412/@comment-28861328-20140521230511

Elveonora wrote: So Kaguya's "Sharingan" just happens to look identical to Sasuke's "Rinnegan" and it goes: Rinnegan-looking Sharingan, Rinnegan, Sharingan, Sharingan-looking Rinnegan? You can't truly believe this and can't expect the author to have thought such a nonsensical thing up. What makes more sense, something that is completely illogical or wrong interpretation?

About which came first, ask Seelentau, perhaps his translations are a bit more clear, not to mention you are prone to be so keen on them.

I've seen the translation.

His translations say the same thing everyone else has told you.

Its a Sharingan and Sasuke's is a Rinnegan. I think that you see Kishimoto calling them two different things, you don't like it, so you try to force the "sensible" conclusion. Which is fine if its your own personal theory, but its not going on an article, because its not a fact. You have to accept that Kaguya's was called Sharingan and Sasuke's Rinnegan, because that is what was told to us. It wasn't left ambiguous. It wasn't "hinted" upon. It was flat out stated that Kaguya's was Sharingan and Sasuke's a Rinnegan.

I really dislike it when you bring "interpretation" into arguments like this because it really doesn't matter how anyone "interprets it". What matters is what was written.