Board Thread:Naruto Discussions/@comment-25645405-20141128183407/@comment-4366149-20141202043534

Seelentau wrote: It wasn't stated or shown, but it's no logical assumption, either. Yin and Yang chakra is chakra made entirely of one of those two energies. They're no elemental natures you apply to chakra, they're characteristics of chakra. For example, if you mix water and dirt in real life, you get mud, right? But you can't mix water with the dirt's taste. No idea if that example helps, but I can't really explain it in any other way. I can't imagine anyone thinking in a different way than I do.^^' And where does it say or show that these characteristics of chakra, as you call them, cannot be combined with elemental releases? (Unless you are now suggesting that all the five basic releases already contain Yin or Yang Releases as well). Keep in mind that I'm not suggesting that canon confirmed that Yin and Yang can be combined with the five basic releases.

When you have to connect a bunch of dots that were not consolidated by the author in order to make a claim, are unable to find any material in canon that dictates the claim or unable to build a rational on such material, are having difficulty or simply unable to express a coherent logic behind the claim, then you have yourself all the features of a wonderful conjecture. Not a speculation, but a conjecture.