Board Thread:Theories and Speculation/@comment-33485854-20180625233306/@comment-33485854-20180630184211

LoneNinja wrote: You aren't disproving what I am saying. Saying Sasuke got half but not really half in that way, still doesn't explain how Sasuke got Rinnegan and Naruto didn't. My point still stands. It's either an inconsistent plot hole or there's more to it than just getting Hagoromo's Chakra. Sasuke got Rinnegan after receiving Hag's Chakra. Therefore, Naruto should've as well based off your logic. That, or Sasuke shouldn't have Rinnegan at all. Either way you look at it, it's a plot hole.

He met the requirements for the Rinnegan before his near death experiance, and Hagoromo granted amped his his Yin half. When he gave him the Seal.

Naruto doesn't have it because he doesn't have Indra's or Hagoromo's Yin Chakra to complement his Yang Chakra.

Edit: It may not sound right, but the best explanation is Hagoromo, while granting them jis Jutsu, also enhanced Naruto's body and Sasuke's mind, the source of Yang and Release. That's the only way I can rationalize a permanet change to their Chakra.

Edit 2: Or the method of converting Energy into Chakra was altered in some way.