Board Thread:Naruto Discussions/@comment-5413572-20140703171400/@comment-5413572-20140704162639

Elveonora wrote: Not to mention Hagoromo's chakra already includes Ashura's as well. So yes, Sasuke indeed has both Indra and Ashura's chakra. If he didn't, there would be no Rinnegan.

But by that logic, Naruto should also have it, as he also received half of Hagaromo's chakra, and with it some of Indra's.

TheUltimate3 wrote:

Fair enough. However, never once have the tailed beast been associated with the Rinnegan. In fact, we don't even know where the Rinnegan showed up first. It is just as likely the tree got the eye because of Kaguya as it is the other way around.

Seelentau wrote: Imagine: There was a tree without eye, but with Chakra fruit. Kaguya ate the fruit, which resulted in the Rinnegan and thus the TT's Rinnegan. When the TT was made into the tree again, it kept the Rinnegan. This is simply based on the fact that the tree nowadays doesn't look like the original tree at all. There is a high possibility that it didn't have the eye before Kaguya ate its fruit.

But that's my point- the Ten Tails (i.e. Shinju + Kaguya) had the Rinnegan when Hamura and Hagaromo fought and sealed it in the latter. Hagaromo later extracted this chakra and used it to create the nine Tailed Beasts, and thus each of them have (and more or less are) fragments of the Ten Tail's chakra. Meanwhile, combining the chakra of Indra and Asura replicated Hagaromo's, subsequently allowing Madara to awaken his diluted purple Rinnegan. So, shouldn't combining the chakra of all nine Tailed Beasts replicate the chakra of the Ten Tails, subsequently allowing Naruto to awaken its Rinnegan?