Board Thread:Consensus Track/@comment-26822192-20200713203154

In Uchiha clan page, there is this description:

Hashirama did not wish for Madara's actions to be held against the rest of the Uchiha...

Not even once did Hashirama ever say something like that. That's a blatant piece of fanfiction that somehow made its way there. Not a single refrence is made either.

Then there is this:

''...a wish that was not followed: his successor as Hokage, Tobirama, was wary of the Uchiha, believing they could never be convinced to fully commit to Konoha's best interests. For this reason he created the Konoha Military Police Force''

That one not only ignores the fact that Tobirama's wariness of Uchiha stemmed from their volatile minds but also directly and completely contradicts the canon. Tobirama says exactly that he gave the police force to the Uchiha so they could have a chance to work with the village.







Even in Obito's (probably) biased account, law enforcement was given to the Uchiha as a sing of trust.

Tobirama also says he trusted many Uchiha like Kagami. Another piece of canon that contradicts the wiki.

And really, thinking logically, what kind of stupid leader would give exclusive control over law enforcement to a clan he believes utterly hopeless and distrusting?

Then there is this part in Tobirama's page:

''Nonetheless, he allowed his past experiences with Madara to affect his judgement of the Uchiha clan in many instances, and he never got rid of his suspicious attitude towards them during his lifetime. ''

Another contradiction of canon. Again, ignores the fact Tobirama was wary of them because of their unpredictability, he even conducted research to make sure he was right. That is not the action of a man who just wants to be biased.

Besides, he makes it clear he was wary of anyone who posed a threat to the village and makes it clear Uchiha had caused troubles frequently even after Madara. The data books and Obito's account support this, that some Uchiha followed in Madara's footsteps and started difficulties.



And really, considering Uchiha's already notorious history and the fact there were many Madara over the years in Shinobi world, it doesn't make sense to say it was just Madara who caused the wariness. There is no way other Indra's reincarnation or unhinged Uchiha's actions are unknown to Tobirama.

My question is why are there such unsupported biased descriptions that no doubt mislead fans in this website? I kept editing them and put the correct references but my edits are constantly undone by another user, Omnibender for no reason. 