Board Thread:Versus Debates/@comment-26107879-20151028182715/@comment-25122992-20151028185734

It'd be a harsh struggle. Both are ninjutsu specialists, but both are able to neutralise them (Madara's Preta Path/Toneri's TSB). However, I'd still give it to Madara because of his taijutsu, close combat experience (which is something like Toneri's weak point) and, what's the most important, Perfect Susanoo mastery. I can't imagine Toneri blocking several PS sword swings even with TSB defence.