Board Thread:Naruto Discussions/@comment-36221354-20180717114536/@comment-3441296-20180805035506

LoneNinja wrote: @J Spencer

I asked for proof, not an opinion on what you think is transpiring in the manga. Kabuto stated the Sharingan can evolve into Rinnegan. This is fact. What you think Madara says is wrong, is irrelevant unless the words that came from his lips were "You're wrong about the Sharingan turning into Rinnegan". Actually, after re-reading the chapter, he states "Don't misunderstand, this power wasn't created by you". All that says is Kabuto didn't create the power Madara holds, according to Madara. So again, the Manga is right until proven wrong.

Whether this means you need Sharingan to get Rinnegan is a whole different story. Momoshiki doesn't seem to have Sharingan. However, Urashiki does seem to have the same Rinnegan as Sasuke thus by some people's logic here, has a Mangekyo since that is what the tomoes represent? Love how you literally called me wrong and then went on to agree with what i said. Its truly amazing. Also...the temoes in the rinnegan do not represent the Magekyo...that was literally never stated or even implied.

Side note, amazed to see this discussion have actually stayed a civil.

LegionZero wrote: J spencer93 wrote:

To address something else you said. Eating a fruit does not give you a forehead sharingan. It didn't give it to Momoshiki (who ate a few), Kinshiki or Urashiki (it's implied all Ototsuki eat them). Why Kaguya got that is unknown, although it was somehow linked to the Fruit. My opinion is, each fruit gains unique properties based on the world it is grown but we won't know (although...did Kishimoto like Turles enough to really make his plot a major story lol) None of the Shikis who came to earth ate a chakra fruit directly from the tree. -.-

Also blatantly wrong, he did eat the fruit. However, this is only confirmed in the anime, and implied in the manga so...it is what it is. They do travel to a world that has a god tree so it seems that they had the opportunity at the least.

What it comes down to is we don't know exactly how you get the rinnegan yet.