Board Thread:Theories and Speculation/@comment-26889573-20151008053113/@comment-1872728-20151017120400

LegionZero wrote: I don't think the manga ever showed the original Shinju. It's shown on this page in Chapter 670: http://www.mangapanda.com/naruto/670/12 LegionZero wrote: Either way both Madara and Kaguya obtained after recieving power directly from the Shinju so it can't be said that these abilities are linked to Kaguya. And technically, the tree did become the 10 Tails. You're right about Kaguya obtaining Rinne Sharingan after absorbing Shinju, but as I said before, Madara obtaining Rinne Sharingan after absorbing Ten Tails Tree Form, which is the combination of both Shinju and Kaguya. And yes, the Shinju did become the Ten Tails, only after being absorbed by Kaguya. If what you said is true, then anyone could manifest Rinne Sharingan after absorbing the Shinju, and that the Shinju grants the consumer the abilities of a Dojutsu, even when the Shinju didn't even have eyes, something needed for Dojutsu. LegionZero wrote: Giving people the ability to produce chakra and giving them chakra is essentially the same thing because without the Shinju chakra wouldn't exist. Its like saying Kakashi's Sharingan allows him to use its techniques vs Kakashi can use the Sharingan. Quit with semantics. My point, is that you need both the Shinju and Kaguya to manifest the Rinne Sharingan. It's true that the Shinju had the abilities of the Rinne Sharingan, but not all of the abilities. The full abilities were granted only when Kaguya absorbed Shinju. And as i said before, you need eyes to have the abilities of a Dojutsu, something the Shinju didn't have.