Board Thread:Theories and Speculation/@comment-9782468-20160223232833/@comment-27233105-20160227232747

How you've analyzed the manga is just so horrendously wrong, it's hard to describe how far off you are from the facts.

A. No, it's not basic common sense--it's propositional fallacy. And no, it's not a coincidence, because we don't know what Zetsu is seeing here. STOP ALLUDING TO WHAT ZETSU IS SEEING, BECAUSE NO ONE KNOWS.

B. How have you managed to continue to ignore that YOU DON'T KNOW HOW LONG ITACHI INTEDED THE JUTSU TO LAST?

C. See points A. and B. and again^^. And since we're agreed that maintaining eye contact (which you're assuming lasts longer than an instant, possibly up to or more than one second) for the duration of the jutsu is what Itachi is doing, why do you think Itachi would maintain the illusion AFTER said damage is done the instant it occurs? You've yet to answer this crucial question, since it's pretty much going to mean you're wrong about when the damage is done--which is likely over the DURATION of the eye contact, lest Itachi would be meaninglessly wasting his chakra, while he could be attacking his suffering opponent.

D. How have you again managed to ignore absolutely crucial info about the function of time distortion. Maybe if I post this example again, and again, and again, you'll realize how it works? (Sound like a familiar operation?)

-- If Itachi puts you under a 72 hr long Tsukuyomi in which you only see dolphins, rainbows, and puppies playing in a field of lillies on a sunny spring day, then you're probably not going to feel ANY pain at all coming out of Tsukuyomi (unless you hate dolphins, rainbows, and puppies). Get how that works? The time doesn't mean a thing if there's no painful observation made by the victim.