Board Thread:Versus Debates/@comment-28885945-20160706220950/@comment-9782468-20160707205102

Kakashi overall is a smarter fighter than Guy, which I think makes up for his lack of raw power.

So I tend to agree that it'd be 50/50, or maybe 55/45 in Guy's favour.

Kakashi's excellent at evading even point-blank powerful attacks, like Kakuzu's combo with Hidan. So Guy would have to get any power attack timed perfectly to land a good hit.

Kakashi isn't as mobile as Guy, so landing a real hit on him would be really difficult. He can't just keep attempting to Raikiri him throughout the fight. Fast as he is with Kamui, I think Guy is fast enough to make it useless against anything but taking out Guy's attacks, like Daytime Tiger (Which would obviously leave Kakashi exhausted, but Guy would be too).

Kakashi's more versatile, Guy's more powerful. Guy's faster and stronger, but Kakashi has Ninjutsu mastery and his better battlefield intelligence. I'm very slightly leaning towards Guy overall, but barely. I could definitely see Kakashi winning, but whoever won would barely make it. In my opinion.