<p>well if we talk about madara, are we talking after obtaining hashirama's cells, cause if so then madara wins. But if we are talking no hashirama cells then it would be really tight.
Lest break this down: Genjutsu- Madara wins though itachis tsukuyomi would trouble madara
Ninjustu: We dont know what sort of justu power madara is packing so you cant say, but itachi would also trouble him here.
Taijustu: Madara isn't known for his taijutsu skills, and itachi could take on kakashi, might guy stated kakashi has beaten him in a few taijutsu battles, so i give this one to itachi.
Speed: Madaras attacks are known for its power and speed, while itachi has been known to be quick also. I say this is a draw, but if this was a durable match then madara wins because of more chakra.
</p><p>And the most important part. Dojutsu: Madara obtained his rinnegann something which itachi could never do, though i dont think he aimed to. Mean while Madara and itachi both have susanoo, and itachi's would destroy madara because it would just suck him up. Itachi takes this one.
</p><p>My point is these two are incomparable because madaras exact abilities are only known to one person who is still living in naruto, Itachi though would be able to give madara a very tough time.
</p>