Thekillman said:
Considering that we have no outside reference of time, it's likely that the conversation started the moment the Transfer started and that it took a bit of time before they fully entered Naruto.
You see how fast Black Zetsu took Yin Kurama? It's pretty much instant. Also Hagoromo emphisized that he wasn't dead yet, implying Narutos life force was not stable.
Legendary Super Saiya-Jin 4 said:
You're forgetting something though, when they all talked to each other subconsciously, they were within close proximity to each other. Not scattered across the whole world like they are now, which was implied to be the reason why Hagoromo wanted Naruto to be the meeting point of all of the beasts
That is actually a good point.
Legendary Super Saiya-Jin 4 said:
In The Last, Naruto never entered SPSM to begin with, so you can't use that as an example. It is mostly believed that he couldn't use it because most of his power was within Kurama when he manifested him outside of his body to fight the Hamura Statue.
I can use that as an example because its canon. "it is believed" essentially means its speculation. Any evidence?
Legendary Super Saiya-Jin 4 said:
and in the new movie, it looks like there will be a new threat as strong as Kaguya if not possibly stronger. So yes, he does still have a need for it.
Naruto didn't know that 10+ years before hand.
Mecha Naruto said:
I believe Hagoromo is right and what he said is true. Hagoromo said that Naruto has the "chakra" of all tailed beast, he is the meeting point, they can talk among themselves there. There is no other meaning to this, it is very clear. Every time a person appears in subconscious they'll appear only because of chakra, and there are multiple example of this, for example- When Naruto and Sasuke clashed with their Rasengan and Chidori they spoke in subconscious mind, momentarily to communicate, convey message, feelings, etc., Kushina and Minato appeared when the seal was opened because they transferred some of their chakra in Naruto. Dan appearing in Tsunade, Obito and Naruto conversation etc.
They heard the 5 Tails thoughts. Bee confirmed they used telepathy. Bee said it was rare, not that it never happened. They can do it, they just dont usually do so because they kinda all hated each other for the longest. Chakra isn't the only way to communicate within the subconscious. Like Killman said, it probably has to do with communicating over long distances. HOWEVER, all through the war, they used Tailed Beast Telepathy. also, chapter for the Naruto/Sasuke connection?
Mecha Naruto said:
Tailed Beasts chakra is bound to this world, when they die with the Jinchuriki they'll come back again, their chakra will regenerate it is not like Kushina, Minato, they can regenerate their chakra, because they are chakra monster. So it is unconfirmed that Naruto lost all tailed beast chakra.
This applies to reforming to their main bodies, it doesn't regenerate in remote locations while the Beast is alive. Kakashi is an example of this. Naruto gave him chakra at 1 point but it ran out and Naruto had to give him more later on.
Mecha Naruto said:
I assume that when 5 tails attacked 8 tails that is when they momentarily linked with each other, if the beasts are linked their Jinchurikis can hear them.
Your assumption is speculation. Be confirmed they have telepathy, and it has occurred WITHOUT sharing chakra.
Mecha Naruto said:
And about the mind transfer it wasn't made up I gave you an example that Naruto never spoke to Gyuki telepathically before, when Naruto contacted the intel division while fighting third Raikage, they made communication with B and Gyuki spoke to Naruto.
Its not Mind Transfer, but good point, but Bee wouldn't have bothered pointing out or emphasize that it was telepathic if it wasn't beast to beast. Also, look at the effects and the way they talked. They stood and talked with their eyes closed and had to ask specifically to be patched through. That didn't happen during the altercation with the 5 Tails. Naruto was also surprised to hear them talking so they obviously wasn't connected via Yamanakas